MacMaster Frank P, Swansburg Rose, Rittenbach Katherine
University of Calgary, Calgary, Canada.
Strategic Clinical Network for Addictions and Mental Health, Edmonton, Canada.
Acad Psychiatry. 2017 Aug;41(4):452-454. doi: 10.1007/s40596-016-0656-2. Epub 2017 Apr 18.
Bibliometrics play an increasingly critical role in the assessment of faculty for promotion and merit increases. Bibliometrics is the statistical analysis of publications, aimed at evaluating their impact. The objective of this study is to describe h-index and citation benchmarks in academic psychiatry.
Faculty lists were acquired from online resources for all academic departments of psychiatry listed as having residency training programs in Canada (as of June 2016). Potential authors were then searched on Web of Science (Thomson Reuters) for their corresponding h-index and total number of citations.
The sample included 1683 faculty members in academic psychiatry departments. Restricted to those with a rank of assistant, associate, or full professor resulted in 1601 faculty members (assistant = 911, associate = 387, full = 303). h-index and total citations differed significantly by academic rank. Both were highest in the full professor rank, followed by associate, then assistant. The range in each, however, was large.
This study provides the initial benchmarks for the h-index and total citations in academic psychiatry. Regardless of any controversies or criticisms of bibliometrics, they are increasingly influencing promotion, merit increases, and grant support. As such, benchmarking by specialties is needed in order to provide needed context.
文献计量学在教师晋升和绩效加薪评估中发挥着越来越关键的作用。文献计量学是对出版物的统计分析,旨在评估其影响力。本研究的目的是描述学术精神病学领域的h指数和引用基准。
从在线资源获取加拿大所有列出有住院医师培训项目的精神病学学术部门的教师名单(截至2016年6月)。然后在科学网(汤森路透)上搜索潜在作者的相应h指数和总引用次数。
样本包括1683名精神病学学术部门的教师。将范围限制在助理教授、副教授或正教授级别,得到1601名教师(助理教授 = 911名,副教授 = 387名,正教授 = 303名)。h指数和总引用次数在学术级别上有显著差异。两者在正教授级别最高,其次是副教授,然后是助理教授。然而,每个级别的范围都很大。
本研究提供了学术精神病学领域h指数和总引用次数的初始基准。无论对文献计量学有任何争议或批评,它们都越来越多地影响晋升、绩效加薪和资助支持。因此,需要按专业进行基准设定,以提供所需的背景信息。