Borges-Yáñez S Aída, Castrejón-Pérez Roberto Carlos, Camacho María Esther Irigoyen
J Clin Pediatr Dent. 2017;41(3):204-213. doi: 10.17796/1053-4628-41.3.204.
Large-scale school-based programs effectively provide health education and preventive strategies. SaludARTE is a school-based program, including supervised tooth brushing, implemented in 51 elementary schools in Mexico City.
To assess the three-month efficacy of supervised tooth brushing in reducing dental plaque, gingival inflammation, and bleeding on probing in schoolchildren participating in SaludARTE.
This was a pragmatic cluster randomized intervention, with two parallel branches. Four randomly selected schools participating in SaludARTE (n=200) and one control school, which did not participate in the program (CG) (n=50), were assessed. Clusters were not randomly allocated to intervention. The main outcomes were as follows: mean percentage gingival units with no inflammation, dental surfaces with no dental plaque, and gingival margins with no bleeding. The independent variable was supervised tooth brushing at school once a day after a meal. Guardians and children responded to a questionnaire on sociodemographic and oral hygiene practices, and children were examined dentally. Mean percentage differences were compared (baseline and follow-up).
A total of 75% of guardians from the intervention group (IG) and 77% from the CG answered the questionnaire. Of these, 89.3% were women, with a mean age of 36.9±8.5 years. No differences in sociodemographic variables were observed between groups, and 151 children from the IG and 35 from the CG were examined at baseline and follow-up. Mean percentage differences for plaque-free surfaces (8.8±28.5%) and healthy gingival units (23.3%±23.2%) were significantly higher in the IG.
The school-supervised tooth brushing program is effective in improving oral hygiene and had a greater impact on plaque and gingivitis than on gingival bleeding. It is necessary to reinforce the oral health education component of the program.
大规模的校本项目能有效提供健康教育和预防策略。SaludARTE是一个在校本项目,包括在墨西哥城的51所小学实施的监督刷牙。
评估在参与SaludARTE的学童中,监督刷牙在减少牙菌斑、牙龈炎症和探诊出血方面的三个月疗效。
这是一项实用的整群随机干预研究,有两个平行分支。对四所随机选择参与SaludARTE的学校(n = 200)和一所未参与该项目的对照学校(CG)(n = 50)进行了评估。整群未随机分配到干预组。主要结果如下:无炎症的牙龈单位平均百分比、无牙菌斑的牙面、无出血的牙龈边缘。自变量是每天饭后在学校进行一次监督刷牙。监护人及儿童回答了关于社会人口统计学和口腔卫生习惯的问卷,并对儿童进行了牙科检查。比较了平均百分比差异(基线和随访)。
干预组(IG)75%的监护人和CG组77%的监护人回答了问卷。其中,89.3%为女性,平均年龄为36.9±8.5岁。两组之间在社会人口统计学变量上未观察到差异,在基线和随访时对IG组的151名儿童和CG组的35名儿童进行了检查。IG组无牙菌斑表面的平均百分比差异(8.8±28.5%)和健康牙龈单位的平均百分比差异(23.3%±23.2%)显著更高。
学校监督刷牙项目在改善口腔卫生方面有效,对牙菌斑和牙龈炎的影响大于对牙龈出血的影响。有必要加强该项目的口腔健康教育部分。