Thomas Donna C, McCabe Patricia, Ballard Kirrie J
a Faculty of Health Sciences , The University of Sydney , Lidcombe , Australia.
Int J Speech Lang Pathol. 2018 Dec;20(7):683-698. doi: 10.1080/17549507.2017.1316423. Epub 2017 Apr 26.
Although speech-language pathologists use parent-delivered home-practice, little is known about the quality of this practice and its relation to treatment efficacy. This study reports both treatment outcomes and fidelity following combined clinician-parent delivery of Rapid Syllable Transition (ReST) treatment.
Five children aged 5:1-11:7 with childhood apraxia of speech received 12 treatment sessions; six clinic-based and six at home, using multiple baselines across participants design. We investigated the children's acquisition of treated pseudo words, generalisation to untreated pseudo and real words, and maintenance of gains. We also assessed parent and clinician treatment fidelity and reliability of perceptual judgements.
Two children improved on all treated behaviours; two showed treatment effect on one of their two treated behaviours, and one child had no treatment effect. Only two children generalised to the majority of untreated items. Variable treatment fidelity was found across parents and aspects of treatment. Child outcome was likely influenced by multiple factors, including treatment fidelity, reliability of perceptual judgements and child factors.
Combined clinician-parent delivery of ReST was less efficacious than previously reported clinician-only delivered ReST. Further investigation of the factors affecting outcome is recommended prior to clinical application of the combined model of service delivery.
尽管言语语言病理学家采用家长指导的家庭练习方法,但对于这种练习的质量及其与治疗效果的关系却知之甚少。本研究报告了临床医生与家长联合开展快速音节转换(ReST)治疗后的治疗结果及治疗依从性。
五名年龄在5岁1个月至11岁7个月之间的儿童言语失用症患者接受了12次治疗;其中6次在诊所进行,6次在家中进行,采用跨参与者的多基线设计。我们调查了儿童对治疗过的假词的习得情况、对未治疗的假词和实词的泛化情况以及治疗效果的维持情况。我们还评估了家长和临床医生的治疗依从性以及感知判断的可靠性。
两名儿童在所有接受治疗的行为上均有改善;两名儿童在其接受治疗的两种行为中的一种上显示出治疗效果,一名儿童没有治疗效果。只有两名儿童将治疗效果泛化到大多数未治疗的项目上。发现家长和治疗环节的治疗依从性存在差异。儿童的治疗结果可能受到多种因素的影响,包括治疗依从性、感知判断的可靠性和儿童自身因素。
临床医生与家长联合开展的ReST治疗效果不如之前报告的仅由临床医生开展的ReST治疗。在临床应用这种联合服务模式之前,建议进一步调查影响治疗效果的因素。