Li Mei, Li Jun, Xia Zhigui, Xiao Ning, Jiang Weikang, Wen Yongkang
National Institute of Parasitic Diseases, Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention; Shanghai, China.
J Infect Dev Ctries. 2017 Apr 30;11(4):287-293. doi: 10.3855/jidc.8394.
Early and accurate diagnosis of imported malaria cases in clusters is crucial for protecting the health of patients and local populations, especially confirmed parasitic persons who are asymptomatic.
A total of 226 gold miners who had stayed in highly endemic areas of Ghana for more than six months and returned in clusters were selected randomly. Blood samples from them were tested with microscopy, nest polymerase chain reaction, and rapid diagnostic test (RDT). The sensitivity, specificity, predictive values, agreement rate, and Youden's index of each of three diagnostic methods were calculated and compared with the defined gold standard. A quick and efficient way to respond to screening such a clustered mobile population was predicted and analyzed by evaluating two assumed results of combining microscopy and RDT with or without symptoms of illness.
The rate of the carriers of malaria parasites in the populations of gold miners was 19.47%, including 39 P. falciparum. Among the three diagnostic methods, the microscopy method showed the highest specificity, while the RDT method showed the highest sensitivity but the lowest specificity in detecting P. falciparum. The assumed results of combining RDT and microscopy with symptoms showed the best results among all the test results in screening P. falciparum.
It was too complex and difficult to catch all parasite carriers in a short period of time among populations with such a complicated situation as that in Shanglin County. A strategy of combing microscopy and RDT for diagnosis is highly recommended.
对聚集性输入性疟疾病例进行早期准确诊断对于保护患者及当地人群的健康至关重要,尤其是确诊的无症状寄生虫感染者。
随机选取226名在加纳高度流行地区停留超过6个月且成群返回的金矿工人。对他们的血样进行显微镜检查、巢式聚合酶链反应和快速诊断检测(RDT)。计算三种诊断方法各自的敏感性、特异性、预测值、符合率和尤登指数,并与既定的金标准进行比较。通过评估显微镜检查和RDT结合有无疾病症状的两种假定结果,预测并分析了一种快速有效的方法来应对此类聚集性流动人群的筛查。
金矿工人人群中疟原虫携带者的比例为19.47%,其中包括39例恶性疟原虫。在三种诊断方法中,显微镜检查法显示出最高的特异性,而RDT法在检测恶性疟原虫时显示出最高的敏感性但最低的特异性。RDT和显微镜检查结合症状的假定结果在所有检测结果中对恶性疟原虫的筛查效果最佳。
在上林县这种复杂情况下的人群中,在短时间内找出所有寄生虫携带者过于复杂和困难。强烈建议采用显微镜检查和RDT相结合的诊断策略。