Makovski Tal
The Open University of Israel, Ra'anana, Israel.
Atten Percept Psychophys. 2017 Jul;79(5):1282-1289. doi: 10.3758/s13414-017-1326-5.
This study presents a new powerful visual illusion, in which simple "open" objects-ones with missing boundaries-are perceived as bigger than the same size, fully "closed" objects. In a series of experiments that employed a continuous-response adjustment procedure, it was found that the lack of vertical boundaries inflated the perceived width of an object, whereas the lack of horizontal boundaries inflated its perceived length. The effect was highly robust and it was replicated across different stimulus types and experimental parameters, with almost all observers exhibiting a strong effect. In contrast to the overestimation of the size of an object due to missing boundaries, the inclusion of inner boundaries within an object caused observers to underestimate its size, suggesting that filled space sometimes shrinks, rather than inflates, the perceived size of an object. The open-object illusion bears practical implications for graphics and design as well as important theoretical implications. Specifically, it indicates that the perception of an object's area is not veridical but rather critically depends on contour closure. It is suggested that the visual system extends the missing boundaries of open contour objects, which results in an overestimation of the object's size.
本研究呈现了一种全新且强大的视觉错觉,即在这种错觉中,简单的“开放”物体(即边界缺失的物体)会被感知为比相同尺寸的完全“封闭”物体更大。在一系列采用连续反应调整程序的实验中,研究发现垂直边界的缺失会夸大物体的感知宽度,而水平边界的缺失则会夸大其感知长度。这种效应非常稳健,并且在不同的刺激类型和实验参数下都能得到重复,几乎所有观察者都表现出强烈的效应。与由于边界缺失导致物体尺寸被高估相反,物体内部包含边界会使观察者低估其尺寸,这表明填充空间有时会缩小而非放大物体的感知尺寸。开放物体错觉对图形和设计具有实际意义,同时也具有重要的理论意义。具体而言,它表明对物体面积的感知并非如实反映,而是关键取决于轮廓闭合。研究表明,视觉系统会延伸开放轮廓物体缺失的边界,从而导致对物体尺寸的高估。