Department of Neuropathology, Sainte-Anne Hospital, 75014, Paris, France.
Department of Genetic and Molecular Biology, Cochin Hospital, AP-HP, 75014, Paris, France.
Brain Pathol. 2018 Jul;28(4):466-474. doi: 10.1111/bpa.12524. Epub 2017 Jun 12.
Clear cell meningioma (CCM) is a rare grade II histopathological subtype that usually occurs in young patients and displays high recurrence rate. Germline SMARCE1 mutations have been described in hereditary forms of this disease and more recently in small syndromic and sporadic CCM series. The diagnostic value of SMARCE1 in distinguishing between CCM and other meningioma variants has not been yet established. The aim of our study was to investigate the status of SMARCE1 in a series of CCMs and its morphological mimickers. We compared the performance of an anti-SMARCE1 antibody and the molecular analysis of the SMARCE1 gene in a retrospective multicenter series of CCMs. All CCMs lossed SMARCE1 immunoexpression. Bi-allelic inactivating events were found by NGS-based sequencing in all of these cases, except for one, which was incompletely explored, but had a wild-type sequence. We then validated the anti-SMARCE1 antibody specificity by analyzing additional 305 pediatric and adult meningiomas of various subtypes and 15 non-meningioma clear cell tumors by SMARCE1 immunohistochemistry. A nuclear immunostaining was preserved in all other meningioma variants, as well as non-meningioma clear cell tumors. In conclusion, our series showed, for the first time, that SMARCE1 immunostaining is a highly sensitive biomarker for CCM, useful as a routine diagnostic biomarker.
透明细胞脑膜瘤(CCM)是一种罕见的 II 级组织病理学亚型,通常发生在年轻患者中,且具有较高的复发率。种系 SMARCE1 突变已在该疾病的遗传性形式中以及最近在小部分综合征和散发性 CCM 系列中被描述。SMARCE1 在区分 CCM 和其他脑膜瘤变体中的诊断价值尚未确定。本研究旨在调查 SMARCE1 在一系列 CCM 及其形态模拟物中的状态。我们比较了抗 SMARCE1 抗体和 SMARCE1 基因的分子分析在回顾性多中心 CCM 系列中的表现。所有 CCM 均丧失了 SMARCE1 免疫表达。除了一个未完全探索但具有野生型序列的病例外,所有这些病例均通过基于 NGS 的测序发现了双等位基因失活事件。然后,我们通过 SMARCE1 免疫组织化学分析了另外 305 例不同亚型的儿科和成人脑膜瘤和 15 例非脑膜瘤透明细胞肿瘤,验证了抗 SMARCE1 抗体的特异性。所有其他脑膜瘤变体以及非脑膜瘤透明细胞肿瘤均保留了核免疫染色。总之,我们的系列首次表明,SMARCE1 免疫染色是 CCM 的一种高度敏感的生物标志物,可用作常规诊断生物标志物。