Smit Eline Suzanne, Dima Alexandra Lelia, Immerzeel Stephanie Annette Maria, van den Putte Bas, Williams Geoffrey Colin
Amsterdam School of Communication Research/ASCoR, Department of Communication Science, University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, Netherlands.
Health Services and Performance Research (HESPER EA 7425), University Claude Bernard Lyon 1, Lyon, France.
J Med Internet Res. 2017 May 8;19(5):e155. doi: 10.2196/jmir.6714.
Web-based health behavior change interventions may be more effective if they offer autonomy-supportive communication facilitating the internalization of motivation for health behavior change. Yet, at this moment no validated tools exist to assess user-perceived autonomy-support of such interventions.
The aim of this study was to develop and validate the virtual climate care questionnaire (VCCQ), a measure of perceived autonomy-support in a virtual care setting.
Items were developed based on existing questionnaires and expert consultation and were pretested among experts and target populations. The virtual climate care questionnaire was administered in relation to Web-based interventions aimed at reducing consumption of alcohol (Study 1; N=230) or cannabis (Study 2; N=228). Item properties, structural validity, and reliability were examined with item-response and classical test theory methods, and convergent and divergent validity via correlations with relevant concepts.
In Study 1, 20 of 23 items formed a one-dimensional scale (alpha=.97; omega=.97; H=.66; mean 4.9 [SD 1.0]; range 1-7) that met the assumptions of monotonicity and invariant item ordering. In Study 2, 16 items fitted these criteria (alpha=.92; H=.45; omega=.93; mean 4.2 [SD 1.1]; range 1-7). Only 15 items remained in the questionnaire in both studies, thus we proceeded to the analyses of the questionnaire's reliability and construct validity with a 15-item version of the virtual climate care questionnaire. Convergent validity of the resulting 15-item virtual climate care questionnaire was confirmed by positive associations with autonomous motivation (Study 1: r=.66, P<.001; Study 2: r=.37, P<.001) and perceived competence for reducing alcohol intake (Study 1: r=.52, P<.001). Divergent validity could only be confirmed by the nonsignificant association with perceived competence for learning (Study 2: r=.05, P=.48).
The virtual climate care questionnaire accurately assessed participants' perceived autonomy-support offered by two Web-based health behavior change interventions. Overall, the scale showed the expected properties and relationships with relevant concepts, and the studies presented suggest this first version of the virtual climate care questionnaire to be reasonably valid and reliable. As a result, the current version may cautiously be used in future research and practice to measure perceived support for autonomy within a virtual care climate. Future research efforts are required that focus on further investigating the virtual climate care questionnaire's divergent validity, on determining the virtual climate care questionnaire's validity and reliability when used in the context of Web-based interventions aimed at improving nonaddictive or other health behaviors, and on developing and validating a short form virtual climate care questionnaire.
如果基于网络的健康行为改变干预措施能够提供自主性支持性沟通,促进健康行为改变动机的内化,那么它们可能会更有效。然而,目前还没有经过验证的工具来评估用户对这类干预措施的自主性支持感知。
本研究的目的是开发并验证虚拟气候关怀问卷(VCCQ),这是一种用于衡量虚拟护理环境中自主性支持感知的工具。
基于现有的问卷和专家咨询开发项目,并在专家和目标人群中进行预测试。虚拟气候关怀问卷是针对旨在减少酒精消费(研究1;N = 230)或大麻消费(研究2;N = 228)的网络干预措施进行施测的。使用项目反应和经典测试理论方法检查项目属性、结构效度和信度,并通过与相关概念的相关性检验收敛效度和区分效度。
在研究1中,23个项目中的20个形成了一个一维量表(α = 0.97;ω = 0.97;H = 0.66;均值4.9 [标准差1.0];范围1 - 7),该量表满足单调性和项目排序不变性的假设。在研究2中,16个项目符合这些标准(α = 0.92;H = 0.45;ω = 0.93;均值4.2 [标准差1.1];范围1 - 7)。在两项研究中,问卷中仅剩下15个项目,因此我们使用虚拟气候关怀问卷的15项版本进行问卷的信度和结构效度分析。所得的15项虚拟气候关怀问卷的收敛效度通过与自主动机的正相关得到证实(研究1:r = 0.66,P < 0.001;研究2:r = 0.37,P < 0.001)以及与减少酒精摄入量的感知能力的正相关得到证实(研究1:r = 0.52,P < 0.001)。区分效度仅通过与学习感知能力的非显著关联得到证实(研究2:r = 0.05,P = 0.48)。
虚拟气候关怀问卷准确评估了两种基于网络的健康行为改变干预措施所提供的参与者的自主性支持感知。总体而言,该量表显示出预期的属性以及与相关概念的关系,并且所呈现的研究表明虚拟气候关怀问卷的第一版具有合理的效度和信度。因此,当前版本可谨慎地用于未来的研究和实践中,以测量虚拟护理环境中对自主性的感知支持。未来需要开展研究工作,重点进一步研究虚拟气候关怀问卷的区分效度,确定在旨在改善非成瘾性或其他健康行为的网络干预措施背景下使用虚拟气候关怀问卷时的效度和信度,并开发和验证一个简短形式的虚拟气候关怀问卷。