Lansdall Claire J, Coyle-Gilchrist Ian T S, Jones P Simon, Vázquez Rodríguez Patricia, Wilcox Alicia, Wehmann Eileen, Dick Katrina M, Robbins Trevor W, Rowe James B
Department of Clinical Neurosciences, University of Cambridge, UK.
University Medical Centre Hamburg-Eppendorf, University of Hamburg, Germany.
Brain. 2017 Jun 1;140(6):1792-1807. doi: 10.1093/brain/awx101.
Apathy and impulsivity are common and disabling consequences of frontotemporal lobar degeneration. They cause substantial carer distress, but their aetiology remains elusive. There are critical limitations to previous studies in this area including (i) the assessment of either apathy or impulsivity alone, despite their frequent co-existence; (ii) the assessment of behavioural changes within single diagnostic groups; and (iii) the use of limited sets of tasks or questions that relate to just one aspect of these multifactorial constructs. We proposed an alternative, dimensional approach that spans behavioural and language variants of frontotemporal dementia, progressive supranuclear palsy and corticobasal syndrome. This accommodates the commonalities of apathy and impulsivity across disorders and reveals their cognitive and anatomical bases. The ability to measure the components of apathy and impulsivity and their associated neural correlates across diagnostic groups would provide better novel targets for pharmacological manipulations, and facilitate new treatment strategies and strengthen translational models. We therefore sought to determine the neurocognitive components of apathy and impulsivity in frontotemporal lobar degeneration syndromes. The frequency and characteristics of apathy and impulsivity were determined by neuropsychological and behavioural assessments in 149 patients and 50 controls from the PIck's disease and Progressive supranuclear palsy Prevalence and INcidence study (PiPPIN). We derived dimensions of apathy and impulsivity using principal component analysis and employed these in volumetric analyses of grey and white matter in a subset of 70 patients (progressive supranuclear palsy, n = 22; corticobasal syndrome, n = 13; behavioural variant, n = 14; primary progressive aphasias, n = 21) and 27 control subjects. Apathy and impulsivity were present across diagnostic groups, despite being criteria for behavioural variant frontotemporal dementia alone. Measures of apathy and impulsivity frequently loaded onto the same components reflecting their overlapping relationship. However, measures from objective tasks, patient-rated questionnaires and carer-rated questionnaires loaded onto separate components and revealed distinct neurobiology. Corticospinal tracts correlated with patients' self-ratings. In contrast, carer ratings correlated with atrophy in established networks for goal-directed behaviour, social cognition, motor control and vegetative functions, including frontostriatal circuits, orbital and temporal polar cortex, and the brainstem. Components reflecting response inhibition deficits correlated with focal frontal cortical atrophy. The dimensional approach to complex behavioural changes arising from frontotemporal lobar degeneration provides new insights into apathy and impulsivity, and the need for a joint therapeutic strategy against them. The separation of objective tests from subjective questionnaires, and patient from carer ratings, has important implications for clinical trial design.awx101media15448041163001.
冷漠和冲动是额颞叶变性常见且致残的后果。它们给照料者带来极大困扰,但其病因仍不明朗。该领域以往研究存在重大局限性,包括:(i)尽管冷漠和冲动常同时存在,但以往研究仅单独评估其中之一;(ii)仅在单一诊断组内评估行为变化;(iii)使用的任务或问题集有限,仅涉及这些多因素结构的一个方面。我们提出了一种替代性的维度方法,涵盖额颞叶痴呆、进行性核上性麻痹和皮质基底节综合征的行为和语言变体。这一方法考虑了不同疾病中冷漠和冲动的共性,并揭示了它们的认知和解剖学基础。能够跨诊断组测量冷漠和冲动的组成部分及其相关神经关联,将为药物干预提供更好的新靶点,促进新的治疗策略,并加强转化模型。因此,我们试图确定额颞叶变性综合征中冷漠和冲动的神经认知成分。通过对来自皮克病和进行性核上性麻痹患病率和发病率研究(PiPPIN)的149例患者和50例对照进行神经心理学和行为评估,确定了冷漠和冲动的频率及特征。我们使用主成分分析得出冷漠和冲动的维度,并将其用于对70例患者(进行性核上性麻痹,n = 22;皮质基底节综合征,n = 13;行为变异型,n = 14;原发性进行性失语,n = 21)和27例对照受试者的灰质和白质体积分析。尽管冷漠和冲动单独来看是行为变异型额颞叶痴呆的标准,但在各诊断组中均有出现。冷漠和冲动的测量指标常常加载到反映它们重叠关系的相同成分上。然而,客观任务、患者自评问卷和照料者自评问卷的测量指标加载到不同成分上,揭示了不同的神经生物学特征。皮质脊髓束与患者自评相关。相比之下,照料者评分与目标导向行为、社会认知、运动控制和植物功能的既定网络萎缩相关,包括额纹状体回路、眶额和颞极皮质以及脑干。反映反应抑制缺陷的成分与额叶皮质局灶性萎缩相关。针对额颞叶变性引起的复杂行为变化的维度方法,为冷漠和冲动以及针对它们的联合治疗策略的必要性提供了新的见解。将客观测试与主观问卷、患者评分与照料者评分分开,对临床试验设计具有重要意义。awx101media15448041163001。