Wang Dunxing, Gao Qin, Li Zhizhong, Song Fei, Ma Liang
a Department of Industrial Engineering , Tsinghua University , Beijing , P.R. China.
b Shanghai Nuclear Engineering Research & Design Ins , Shanghai , P.R. China.
Ergonomics. 2017 Dec;60(12):1634-1652. doi: 10.1080/00140139.2017.1329941. Epub 2017 May 19.
This study aims to develop a taxonomy of coordination behaviours during emergencies in nuclear power plants (NPPs). We summarised basic coordination behaviours from literature in aviation, health care and nuclear field and identified coordination behaviours specific to the nuclear domain by interviewing and surveying control crew operators. The established taxonomy includes 7 workflow stages and 24 basic coordination behaviours. To evaluate the reliability and feasibility of the taxonomy, we analysed 12 videos of operators' training sessions by coding coordination behaviours with the taxonomy and the inter-rater reliability was acceptable. Further analysis of the frequency, the duration and the direction of the coordination behaviours revealed four coordination problems. This taxonomy provides a foundation of systematic observation of coordination behaviours among NPP crews, advances researchers' understanding of the coordination mechanism during emergencies in NPPs and facilitate the possibility to deepen the understanding of the relationships between coordination behaviours and team performance. Practitioner Summary: A taxonomy of coordination behaviours during emergencies in nuclear power plants was developed. Reliability and feasibility of the taxonomy was verified through the analysis of 12 training sessions. The taxonomy can serve as an observation system for analysis of coordination behaviours and help to identify coordination problems of control crews.
本研究旨在制定核电站(NPPs)应急期间协调行为的分类法。我们从航空、医疗保健和核领域的文献中总结了基本协调行为,并通过对控制人员操作员进行访谈和调查,确定了核领域特有的协调行为。所建立的分类法包括7个工作流程阶段和24种基本协调行为。为了评估分类法的可靠性和可行性,我们通过用该分类法对协调行为进行编码,分析了12段操作员培训课程视频,评分者间信度是可接受的。对协调行为的频率、持续时间和方向的进一步分析揭示了四个协调问题。这种分类法为系统观察核电站工作人员之间的协调行为提供了基础,增进了研究人员对核电站应急期间协调机制的理解,并有助于加深对协调行为与团队绩效之间关系的理解。从业者总结:制定了核电站应急期间协调行为的分类法。通过对12次培训课程的分析验证了分类法的可靠性和可行性。该分类法可作为分析协调行为的观察系统,并有助于识别控制人员的协调问题。