Mahadevappa Asha, Nisha Thattamparambil Gopalakrishnan, Manjunath Gubbanna V
Associate Professor, Department of Pathology, JSS Medical College, JSS University, Mysore, Karnataka, India.
Assistant Professor, Department of Pathology, Yenepoya Medical College, Mangalore, Karnataka, India.
J Clin Diagn Res. 2017 Mar;11(3):EC01-EC06. doi: 10.7860/JCDR/2017/24454.9323. Epub 2017 Mar 1.
The most common malignant tumour among women is breast carcinoma. Early lesions of the breast including carcinoma are potentially curable if treated properly in the era of breast conservative therapy. For this purpose different diagnostic strategies are in practice. Intra operative Imprint Cytology (IC) and Frozen Section (FS) have a role in spite of the intense recognition of aspiration cytology in the following settings: inconclusive cytological/core biopsy findings; for evaluation of lumpectomy margins and intra operative nodal status. Both IC and FS are dependable intra operative diagnostic consultation modalities and provide accurate results in minutes thereby making appropriate therapeutic decision.
To study the IC and FS features of breast lesions with correlation of final Histopathologic (HP) diagnosis and to determine its diagnostic accuracy.
This was a descriptive cross-sectional study conducted in the Department of Pathology, JSS Medical College, JSS University, Mysuru over a period of two years (October 2011-September 2013). A total of 62 cases of surgically resected breast specimens were evaluated for features of IC, FS and correlation with HP diagnosis. After describing gross features, representative tissue fragment was taken, three imprint smears were made and same tissue fragment was subjected to FS and later for routine HP processing. Slides prepared by IC, FS were interpreted and later correlated with HP diagnosis. Statistical analysis was done with SPSS for windows (version 16.0) by applying appropriate tests.
Out of 62 cases, 33(53.23%) were malignant and 29(46.77%) were benign. Sensitivity, specificity and accuracy of IC were 100%, 96.43% and 98.36% and for FS were 100%, 96.55% and 98.39% respectively. p-value for both were <0.001 indicating significant correlation with HP study.
IC is a simple, accurate, rapid and cost effective diagnostic tool intra operatively where services for FS are not available. It preserves crisp cellular and nuclear detail. FS tissue architecture strongly approximates permanent HP sections but is frequently hampered by freezing artifact. But FS is able to differentiate carcinoma in situ and infiltrative lesions from benign breast lesions. Thus, IC and FS together offer a more reliable diagnosis; hence, it is always useful to prepare both the slides intra operatively. HP study still remains the gold standard in final diagnosis of any breast lesion. In surgical pathology, the correlation of intra operative IC and FS diagnosis with the final HP diagnosis form an essential part of quality assurance activity.
女性中最常见的恶性肿瘤是乳腺癌。在乳房保守治疗时代,如果早期乳房病变(包括癌)得到妥善治疗,是有可能治愈的。为此,实践中采用了不同的诊断策略。尽管细针穿刺细胞学检查在以下情况中得到广泛认可,但术中印片细胞学检查(IC)和冰冻切片检查(FS)仍发挥着作用:细胞学/核心活检结果不明确;用于评估肿块切除边缘和术中淋巴结状态。IC和FS都是可靠的术中诊断咨询方式,能在几分钟内提供准确结果,从而做出合适的治疗决策。
研究乳房病变的IC和FS特征,并与最终组织病理学(HP)诊断结果进行相关性分析,以确定其诊断准确性。
这是一项描述性横断面研究,在迈索尔市JSS大学JSS医学院病理科进行,为期两年(2011年10月至2013年9月)。共对62例手术切除的乳房标本进行了IC、FS特征评估,并与HP诊断结果进行相关性分析。描述大体特征后,取代表性组织块,制作3张印片涂片,同一组织块进行FS检查,随后进行常规HP处理。对IC、FS制备的玻片进行解读,然后与HP诊断结果进行相关性分析。使用适用于Windows的SPSS(版本16.0)进行统计分析。
62例病例中,33例(53.23%)为恶性,29例(46.77%)为良性。IC的敏感性、特异性和准确性分别为100%、96.43%和98.36%,FS的敏感性、特异性和准确性分别为100%、96.55%和98.39%。两者的p值均<0.001,表明与HP研究有显著相关性。
在无法提供FS服务的术中,IC是一种简单、准确、快速且经济高效的诊断工具。它能保留清晰的细胞和核细节。FS的组织结构与永久性HP切片非常相似,但常受冷冻假象的影响。不过,FS能够区分原位癌和浸润性病变与良性乳房病变。因此,IC和FS共同提供了更可靠的诊断;所以,术中同时制备两种玻片总是很有用的。HP研究仍然是任何乳房病变最终诊断的金标准。在外科病理学中,术中IC和FS诊断与最终HP诊断的相关性是质量保证活动的重要组成部分。