Keren Daniela, Lockyer Jocelyn, Ellaway Rachel H
Cumming School of Medicine, University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta, Canada.
Perspect Med Educ. 2017 Oct;6(5):311-318. doi: 10.1007/s40037-017-0358-9.
Medical students study in social groups, which influence their learning, but few studies have investigated the characteristics of study groups and the impacts they have on students' learning. A scoping review was conducted on the topic of informal social studying and learning within medical education with the aim of appraising what is known regarding medical student attitudes to group study, the impact of group study on participants, and the methods that have been employed to study this.
Using Arksey and O'Malley's scoping review principles, MEDLINE, EMBASE and CINAHL were searched, along with hand-searching and a targeted search of the grey literature; 18 peer reviewed and 17 grey literature records were included.
Thematic conceptual analysis identified a number of themes, including: the nature of group study; the utility and value of group studying including social learning facilitating student engagement, social learning as a source of motivation and accountability, and social learning as a source of wellbeing; and student preferences related to group studying, including its homophilic nature, transgressiveness, and effectiveness. Despite these emerging factors, the evidence base for this phenomenon is small.
The findings in this scoping review demonstrate a clear role for social interaction outside of the classroom, and encourage us to consider the factors in student networking, and the implications of this on medical students' academics. We also highlight areas in need of future research to allow us to better situate informal social learning within medical education and to enable educators to support this phenomenon.
医学生以小组形式学习,这种方式会影响他们的学习,但很少有研究调查学习小组的特征及其对学生学习的影响。针对医学教育中的非正式社交学习这一主题进行了一项范围综述,目的是评估关于医学生对小组学习的态度、小组学习对参与者的影响以及用于研究此现象的方法的现有知识。
采用阿克西和奥马利的范围综述原则,检索了MEDLINE、EMBASE和CINAHL数据库,同时进行了手工检索和对灰色文献的定向检索;纳入了18篇同行评审文献和17篇灰色文献记录。
主题概念分析确定了若干主题,包括:小组学习的性质;小组学习的效用和价值,包括促进学生参与的社交学习、作为动机和责任感来源的社交学习以及作为幸福感来源的社交学习;以及与小组学习相关的学生偏好,包括其同类相聚的性质、违规性和有效性。尽管存在这些新出现的因素,但这一现象的证据基础仍然薄弱。
本范围综述的结果表明课堂外的社交互动具有明确作用,并鼓励我们考虑学生社交网络中的因素及其对医学生学业的影响。我们还强调了未来需要研究的领域,以便我们能更好地将非正式社交学习置于医学教育中,并使教育工作者能够支持这一现象。