Department of Family Medicine, Schulich School of Medicine and Dentistry, London, Canada.
Department of Community Health Sciences, University of Calgary, Calgary, Canada.
Teach Learn Med. 2020 Aug-Sep;32(4):353-361. doi: 10.1080/10401334.2020.1733579. Epub 2020 Mar 16.
Social studying and learning (SSL) is any independent, elective, self-directed and self-organized approach to learning that involves students working with their peers for the purposes of study, learning, or revision. While in-class collaborative learning has been relatively well-explored, very little is known about how medical students engage in informal SSL or about the impacts it can have. The purpose of this study was to explore medical students' practices and perceptions regarding SSL, and the ways in which this shaped their overall learning experiences. A constructivist grounded theory study was conducted at the University of Calgary. Data were collected from 23 semi-structured student interviews, which were audio recorded and transcribed. Data were analyzed using iterative data collection, memo-ing, and focused coding. Despite SSL being a common part of students' medical school experience and something that was promoted by academic advisors, how students actually engaged with SSL varied substantially, including who made use of SSL, how they made use of it, the size and focus of SSL groups, how these groups functioned, and what individuals sought to get out of them. Some students found SSL helped them to be more efficient and focused in their studying, while others benefited from comparing their knowledge and skills with those of their peers. Not everyone benefited, as some students found SSL stressful, unproductive, or socially uncomfortable. While student engagement in SSL was an enabler of academic success for some it could also be an indicator of social isolation and low self-esteem for others. : Understanding how SSL can influence student experiences has the potential to inform students how and why they might engage in SSL, and it can help educators better support their students, particularly in those schools that actively encourage SSL.
社会学习和学习(SSL)是任何独立的、选修的、自我指导的和自我组织的学习方法,涉及学生与同伴合作学习、学习或复习。虽然课堂合作学习已经得到了相对充分的探索,但对于医学生如何参与非正式 SSL 以及它可能产生的影响知之甚少。本研究旨在探讨医学生在 SSL 方面的实践和看法,以及这些实践如何塑造他们的整体学习体验。在卡尔加里大学进行了一项建构主义扎根理论研究。从 23 名半结构化学生访谈中收集数据,这些访谈进行了录音和转录。使用迭代数据收集、备忘录和重点编码对数据进行分析。尽管 SSL 是学生医学院经历的常见部分,也是学术顾问所倡导的,但学生实际参与 SSL 的方式差异很大,包括谁利用 SSL、如何利用 SSL、SSL 小组的规模和重点、这些小组的运作方式以及个人希望从中获得什么。一些学生发现 SSL 帮助他们更有效地专注于学习,而另一些学生则从与同龄人比较知识和技能中受益。并非每个人都受益,因为一些学生发现 SSL 有压力、效率低下或社交不舒服。虽然学生参与 SSL 对一些人来说是学术成功的推动者,但对另一些人来说,它也可能是社交孤立和低自尊的指标。了解 SSL 如何影响学生体验有可能告知学生他们为什么以及为什么要参与 SSL,并帮助教育工作者更好地支持他们的学生,特别是在那些积极鼓励 SSL 的学校。