Katch Victor L, Marks Charles C, Becque M Daniel, Moorehead Catherine, Rocchini Albert
Behnke Laboratory for Body Composition Research, Department of Movement Science, Division of Kinesiology, and Section of Pediatric Cardiology, Department of Pediatrics-School of Medicine, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109-2240.
Exercise Science Program, School of Health Sciences, Oakland University, Rochester, Michigan 48309.
Am J Hum Biol. 1990;2(5):543-551. doi: 10.1002/ajhb.1310020510.
To test if obese adolescents systematically conserve energy, comparisons of basal metabolic rate (BMR) of obese, normal, and lean male and female adolescents were made. Obese had eleevated values by as much as 23% (P ≤ 0.05) expressed as kJ · 24 hr compared to the normal and lean. When indexed to body mass (kJ · kg-BM · hr ), the BMR for the obese was depressed by as much as -53% (P ≤ 0.01), and when indexed to fat free mass (kJ · kg-FFM · hr ) it was depressed by -33% compared to normal and lean adolescents. A "theoretical metabolic rate" (TMR), based on the observed fat free mass, fat mass, and their thermal equivalents, was proposed as a theoretical way to properly index basal metabolism, referenced to body composition. Comparisons of the TMR between the obese, normal, and lean revealed that the obese values were depressed by an average -22% (P ≤ 0.05). In comparison, differences in TMR between the normal and lean males and females were no larger than 8% (ns). It was concluded that since both the observed BMR (expressed relative to body composition), and the derived TMR values were depressed for the obese compared to the normal and lean adolescent, the data suggest an energy saving hypothesis for obese adolescents.
为了测试肥胖青少年是否会系统性地保存能量,研究人员对肥胖、正常体重和偏瘦的男性及女性青少年的基础代谢率(BMR)进行了比较。与正常体重和偏瘦青少年相比,肥胖青少年以kJ·24小时为单位的基础代谢率值升高了23%(P≤0.05)。当以体重(kJ·kg-BM·hr)为指标时,肥胖青少年的基础代谢率下降了53%(P≤0.01),而以去脂体重(kJ·kg-FFM·hr)为指标时,与正常体重和偏瘦青少年相比下降了33%。基于观察到的去脂体重、脂肪量及其热当量,提出了一种“理论代谢率”(TMR),作为一种根据身体成分正确衡量基础代谢的理论方法。肥胖、正常体重和偏瘦青少年之间的理论代谢率比较显示,肥胖青少年的数值平均下降了22%(P≤0.05)。相比之下,正常体重和偏瘦的男性及女性之间的理论代谢率差异不超过8%(无显著性差异)。研究得出结论,由于与正常体重和偏瘦青少年相比,肥胖青少年观察到的基础代谢率(相对于身体成分表示)和推导得出的理论代谢率值均下降,数据表明肥胖青少年存在能量保存假说。