College of Bioscience and Biotechnology, Hunan Agricultural University, Changsha, China.
Analyst. 2017 Jun 21;142(12):2229-2238. doi: 10.1039/c7an00280g. Epub 2017 May 24.
Calibration model transfer has played a prominent role in the practical application of NIR spectral analysis. The change of instruments and sample physical states may lead to variation of the NIR spectrum, which results in the applicability of the model in judicatory practice being unsatisfactory. Therefore, a transfer for the calibration model considering both the variation of instruments and sample states is a necessity to ensure its availability. In this paper, a novel approach, namely canonical correlation analysis coupled with wavelet transform (WTCCA), was proposed for calibration transfer between two near infrared spectrometers (a portable and a laboratory instrument), and simultaneously, among three physical states (tobacco powder, tobacco filament and intact leaf) to determine the content of total sugars, reducing sugars, and nicotine in tobacco leaf samples, respectively. Wavelet transform (WT) is introduced to reduce noise and deduct background shifts from the spectra by compression, and then, calibration transfer by canonical correlation analysis (CTCCA) extracts the compressed spectral similarities using canonical scores for spectra correction. Three similar standardization algorithms, including piecewise direct standardization (PDS), piecewise direct standardization with wavelet transform (WTPDS), and CTCCA were compared with WTCCA to evaluate its relative performance. The obtained results showed that the employment of WTCCA yielded the lowest root mean standard error of prediction (RMSEP) on the three analytes in three physical states. For the tobacco powder dataset, the RMSEP values had a reduction of 25.83%, 13.96%, and 14.22% compared with the values of direct prediction without spectra transfer, respectively. For the tobacco filament dataset, the corresponding values were decreased by 18.06%, 14.90%, and 13.61% and for the intact leaf dataset, the values had dropped by 10.70%, 18.21%, and 28.21%, respectively. In summary, the comprehensive investigation carried out in the present work shows that WTCCA is very appropriate for correcting the variations caused by the change of machines and sample states. Furthermore, WTCCA is a promising calibration transfer method which can be recommended for on-line/in-line application.
定标模型传递在近红外光谱分析的实际应用中发挥了突出的作用。仪器和样品物理状态的变化可能导致近红外光谱的变化,从而导致模型在司法实践中的适用性不尽人意。因此,需要进行同时考虑仪器和样品状态变化的定标模型传递,以确保其可用性。在本文中,提出了一种新的方法,即典型相关分析与小波变换(WTCCA)相结合,用于两种近红外光谱仪(便携式和实验室仪器)之间以及三种物理状态(烟末、烟丝和完整叶片)之间的定标传递,分别用于确定烟叶样品中总糖、还原糖和尼古丁的含量。小波变换(WT)用于通过压缩减少光谱中的噪声和扣除背景漂移,然后,典型相关分析(CTCCA)通过典型得分提取压缩光谱相似性,用于光谱校正。三种类似的标准化算法,包括分段直接标准化(PDS)、带小波变换的分段直接标准化(WTPDS)和 CTCCA 与 WTCCA 进行了比较,以评估其相对性能。结果表明,在三种物理状态下,WTCCA 在三种分析物上的预测均方根标准误差(RMSEP)最低。对于烟末数据集,与没有光谱传递的直接预测值相比,RMSEP 值分别降低了 25.83%、13.96%和 14.22%。对于烟丝数据集,相应的值分别降低了 18.06%、14.90%和 13.61%,对于完整叶片数据集,值分别降低了 10.70%、18.21%和 28.21%。总之,本工作进行的综合研究表明,WTCCA 非常适合校正由机器和样品状态变化引起的变化。此外,WTCCA 是一种很有前途的定标传递方法,可以推荐用于在线/在线应用。