Lopez G A, Brønd J C, Andersen L B, Dencker M, Arvidsson D
Department of Human Nutrition, National University of Colombia, Bogotá, Colombia.
Department of Sport Science and Clinical Biomechanics, University of Southern Denmark, Odense, Denmark.
Scand J Med Sci Sports. 2018 Feb;28(2):487-495. doi: 10.1111/sms.12920. Epub 2017 Jun 28.
SenseWear Armband (SW) is a multisensor monitor to assess physical activity and energy expenditure. Its prediction algorithms have been updated periodically. The aim was to validate SW in children, adolescents, and adults. The most recent SW algorithm 5.2 (SW5.2) and the previous version 2.2 (SW2.2) were evaluated for estimation of energy expenditure during semi-structured activities in 35 children, 31 adolescents, and 36 adults with indirect calorimetry as reference. Energy expenditure estimated from waist-worn ActiGraph GT3X+ data (AG) was used for comparison. Improvements in measurement errors were demonstrated with SW5.2 compared to SW2.2, especially in children and for biking. The overall mean absolute percent error with SW5.2 was 24% in children, 23% in adolescents, and 20% in adults. The error was larger for sitting and standing (23%-32%) and for basketball and biking (19%-35%), compared to walking and running (8%-20%). The overall mean absolute error with AG was 28% in children, 22% in adolescents, and 28% in adults. The absolute percent error for biking was 32%-74% with AG. In general, SW and AG underestimated energy expenditure. However, both methods demonstrated a proportional bias, with increasing underestimation for increasing energy expenditure level, in addition to the large individual error. SW provides measures of energy expenditure level with similar accuracy in children, adolescents, and adults with the improvements in the updated algorithms. Although SW captures biking better than AG, these methods share remaining measurements errors requiring further improvements for accurate measures of physical activity and energy expenditure in clinical and epidemiological research.
SenseWear臂带(SW)是一种用于评估身体活动和能量消耗的多传感器监测器。其预测算法会定期更新。目的是在儿童、青少年和成年人中验证SW。评估了最新的SW算法5.2(SW5.2)和先前版本2.2(SW2.2)在35名儿童、31名青少年和36名成年人进行半结构化活动期间估计能量消耗的情况,以间接测热法作为参考。使用从腰部佩戴的ActiGraph GT3X +数据(AG)估计的能量消耗进行比较。与SW2.2相比,SW5.2在测量误差方面有改进,尤其是在儿童中以及骑自行车时。SW5.2的总体平均绝对百分比误差在儿童中为24%,在青少年中为23%,在成年人中为20%。与步行和跑步(8%-20%)相比,坐着和站立时(23%-32%)以及篮球和骑自行车时(19%-35%)的误差更大。AG的总体平均绝对误差在儿童中为28%,在青少年中为22%,在成年人中为28%。AG测量骑自行车时的绝对百分比误差为32%-74%。一般来说,SW和AG都低估了能量消耗。然而,除了个体误差较大外,两种方法都显示出比例偏差,随着能量消耗水平的增加,低估程度也增加。随着算法的更新改进,SW在儿童、青少年和成年人中提供了具有相似准确性的能量消耗水平测量值。虽然SW比AG更能捕捉到骑自行车的情况,但这些方法仍存在测量误差,在临床和流行病学研究中,需要进一步改进以准确测量身体活动和能量消耗。