School of Biosciences, Faculty of Science, The University of Nottingham Malaysia Campus, Jalan Broga, 43500 Semenyih, Selangor, Malaysia; Department of Biochemistry, Faculty of Science, Kebbi State University of Science and Technology Aleiro, PMB 1144, Kebbi State, Nigeria.
School of Pharmacy, Faculty of Science, The University of Nottingham Malaysia Campus, Jalan Broga, 43500 Semenyih, Selangor, Malaysia.
Phytomedicine. 2017 Jul 1;30:74-84. doi: 10.1016/j.phymed.2017.03.004. Epub 2017 Mar 10.
γ-Tocotrienol, a vitamin E isomer possesses pronounced in vitro anticancer activities. However, the in vivo potency has been limited by hardly achievable therapeutic levels owing to inefficient high-dose oral delivery which leads to subsequent metabolic degradation. Jerantinine A, an Aspidosperma alkaloid, originally isolated from Tabernaemontana corymbosa, has proved to possess interesting anticancer activities. However, jerantinine A also induces toxicity to non-cancerous cells.
We adopted a combinatorial approach with the joint application of γ-tocotrienol and jerantinine A at lower concentrations in order to minimize toxicity towards non-cancerous cells while improving the potency on brain cancer cells.
The antiproliferative potency of individual γ-tocotrienol and jerantinine A as well as combined in low-concentration was firstly evaluated on U87MG cancer and MRC5 normal cells. Morphological changes, DNA damage patterns, cell cycle arrests and the effects of individual and combined low-concentration compounds on microtubules were then investigated. Finally, the potential roles of caspase enzymes and apoptosis-related proteins in mediating the apoptotic mechanisms were investigated using apoptosis antibody array, ELISA and Western blotting analysis.
Combinatorial study between γ-tocotrienol at a concentration range (0-24µg/ml) and fixed IC concentration of jerantinine A (0.16µg/ml) induced a potent antiproliferative effect on U87MG cells and led to a reduction on the new half maximal inhibitory concentration of γ-tocotrienol (i.e.IC=1.29µg/ml) as compared to that of individual γ-tocotrienol (i.e. IC=3.17µg/ml). A reduction on undesirable toxicity to MRC5 normal cells was also observed. G0/G1 cell cycle arrest was evident on U87MG cells receiving IC of individual γ-tocotrienol and combined low-concentration compounds (1.29µg/ml γ-tocotrienol + 0.16µg/ml jerantinine A), whereas, a profound G2/M arrest was evident on cells treated with IC of individual jerantinine A. Additionally, individual jerantinine A and combined compounds (except individual γ-tocotrienol) caused a disruption of microtubule networks triggering Fas- and p53-induced apoptosis mediated via the death receptor and mitochondrial pathways.
These findings demonstrated that the combined use of lower concentrations of γ-tocotrienol and jerantinine A induced potent cytotoxic effects on U87MG cancer cells resulting in a reduction on the required individual concentrations and thereby minimizing toxicity of jerantinine A towards non-cancerous MRC5 cells as well as probably overcoming the high-dose limiting application of γ-tocotrienol. The multi-targeted mechanisms of action of the combination approach have shown a therapeutic potential against brain cancer in vitro and therefore, further in vivo investigations using a suitable animal model should be the way forward.
γ-生育三烯酚,一种维生素 E 异构体,具有显著的体外抗癌活性。然而,由于高效剂量口服递送难以实现,导致随后的代谢降解,其体内效力受到限制。杰兰汀 A,一种最初从 Tabernaemontana corymbosa 中分离出来的 Aspidosperma 生物碱,已被证明具有有趣的抗癌活性。然而,杰兰汀 A 也会对非癌细胞产生毒性。
我们采用联合应用γ-生育三烯酚和杰兰汀 A 的组合方法,以较低浓度使用,从而在提高脑癌细胞效力的同时,最大限度地降低对非癌细胞的毒性。
首先在 U87MG 癌症和 MRC5 正常细胞上评估单独的 γ-生育三烯酚和杰兰汀 A 以及低浓度联合的增殖抑制效力。然后研究形态变化、DNA 损伤模式、细胞周期停滞以及单独和联合低浓度化合物对微管的影响。最后,使用凋亡抗体阵列、ELISA 和 Western blot 分析研究 caspase 酶和凋亡相关蛋白在介导凋亡机制中的潜在作用。
在 0-24μg/ml 浓度范围内的 γ-生育三烯酚与固定的杰兰汀 A(0.16μg/ml)的组合研究在 U87MG 细胞上诱导了有效的增殖抑制作用,并降低了单独使用 γ-生育三烯酚的新半最大抑制浓度(即 IC=1.29μg/ml),而不是单独使用 γ-生育三烯酚(即 IC=3.17μg/ml)。还观察到对 MRC5 正常细胞的不良毒性降低。在接受单独的 γ-生育三烯酚和联合低浓度化合物(1.29μg/ml γ-生育三烯酚+0.16μg/ml 杰兰汀 A)的 U87MG 细胞中观察到 G0/G1 细胞周期停滞,而在单独用杰兰汀 A 处理的细胞中观察到明显的 G2/M 停滞。此外,单独的杰兰汀 A 和联合化合物(除单独的 γ-生育三烯酚外)会破坏微管网络,通过死亡受体和线粒体途径引发 Fas 和 p53 诱导的凋亡。
这些发现表明,联合使用较低浓度的γ-生育三烯酚和杰兰汀 A 对 U87MG 癌细胞产生强烈的细胞毒性作用,从而降低了单独使用的浓度,从而最大限度地降低了杰兰汀 A 对非癌细胞 MRC5 的毒性,并且可能克服了 γ-生育三烯酚的高剂量限制应用。联合应用的多靶点作用机制显示出体外治疗脑癌的潜力,因此,应使用合适的动物模型进行进一步的体内研究。