Cummings Janet R, Ji Xu, Allen Lindsay, Lally Cathy, Druss Benjamin G
Department of Health Policy and Management, Rollins School of Public Health, Emory University, Atlanta, Georgia
Department of Health Policy and Management, Rollins School of Public Health, Emory University, Atlanta, Georgia.
Pediatrics. 2017 Jun;139(6). doi: 10.1542/peds.2016-2444. Epub 2017 May 16.
We estimated racial/ethnic differences in attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) care quality and treatment continuity among Medicaid-enrolled children.
Using Medicaid data from 9 states (2008 to 2011), we identified 172 322 youth (age 6 to 12) initiating ADHD medication. Outcome measures included: (1) adequate follow-up care in the (a) initiation and (b) continuation and maintenance (C&M) treatment phases; (2) combined treatment with medication and psychotherapy (versus medication alone); (3) medication discontinuation; and (4) treatment disengagement (ie, discontinued medication and received no psychotherapy). Logistic regressions controlled for confounding measures.
Among those initiating medication, three-fifths received adequate follow-up care in the initiation and C&M phases, and under two-fifths received combined treatment. Compared with whites, African American youth were less likely to receive adequate follow-up in either phase ( < .05), whereas Hispanic youth were more likely to receive adequate follow-up in the C&M phase ( < .001). African American and Hispanic youth were more likely than whites to receive combined treatment ( < .05). Over three-fifths discontinued medication, and over four-tenths disengaged from treatment. Compared with whites, African American and Hispanic children were 22.4% and 16.7% points more likely to discontinue medication, and 13.1% and 9.4% points more likely to disengage from treatment, respectively ( < .001).
Care quality for Medicaid-enrolled youth initiating ADHD medication is poor, and racial/ethnic differences in these measures are mixed. The most important disparities occur in the higher rates of medication discontinuation among minorities, which translate into higher rates of treatment disengagement because most youth discontinuing medication receive no psychotherapy.
我们评估了医疗补助计划参保儿童在注意力缺陷多动障碍(ADHD)护理质量和治疗连续性方面的种族/民族差异。
利用9个州(2008年至2011年)的医疗补助数据,我们确定了172322名开始使用ADHD药物治疗的青少年(6至12岁)。结果指标包括:(1)在(a)起始治疗阶段和(b)持续及维持(C&M)治疗阶段的充分随访护理;(2)药物治疗与心理治疗联合使用(与单纯药物治疗相比);(3)药物停用;以及(4)治疗中断(即停用药物且未接受心理治疗)。逻辑回归控制了混杂因素。
在开始用药的患者中,五分之三的人在起始治疗阶段和C&M阶段接受了充分的随访护理,不到五分之二的人接受了联合治疗。与白人相比,非裔美国青少年在任一阶段接受充分随访的可能性较小(P<0.05),而西班牙裔青少年在C&M阶段接受充分随访的可能性较大(P<0.001)。非裔美国人和西班牙裔青少年比白人更有可能接受联合治疗(P<0.05)。超过五分之三的人停用了药物,超过十分之四的人中断了治疗。与白人相比,非裔美国儿童和西班牙裔儿童停用药物的可能性分别高出22.4个百分点和16.7个百分点,中断治疗的可能性分别高出13.1个百分点和9.4个百分点(P<0.001)。
开始使用ADHD药物治疗的医疗补助计划参保青少年的护理质量较差,这些指标中的种族/民族差异参差不齐。最重要的差异在于少数族裔中药物停用率较高,这导致治疗中断率较高,因为大多数停用药物的青少年未接受心理治疗。