Spicer Greg S
Institute of Molecular Medical Sciences, 460 Page Mill Road, Palo Alto, California, 94306.
Committee on Evolutionary Biology, University of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, 60637.
Evolution. 1993 Aug;47(4):1240-1254. doi: 10.1111/j.1558-5646.1993.tb02150.x.
Two rate tests for assessing natural selection on quantitative traits are discussed for their usefulness in macroevolutionary and adaptational studies. The underlying assumptions and parameter estimation for the constant-heritability (CH) and mutation-drift-equilibrium (MDE) models, which are the bases for these tests, are discussed. The purpose of these rate tests is to determine whether morphological change has occurred either too fast to be explained by neutral drift, which suggests directional selection, or too slow, which suggests stabilizing selection. Previous formulations of these rate tests have ignored the phylogenetic component. Several models of evolution are considered to help account for phylogeny in the context of rate tests. The MDE rate test for stabilizing selection was performed on nine morphological characters among several species of the Drosophila virilis species group. These tests can be interpreted to suggest that stabilizing selection has probably been a major factor in producing the observed similarity among the Drosophila species examined.
本文讨论了两种用于评估数量性状自然选择的速率测试,探讨了它们在宏观进化和适应性研究中的实用性。文中还讨论了作为这些测试基础的恒定遗传力(CH)模型和突变-漂变平衡(MDE)模型的基本假设及参数估计。这些速率测试的目的是确定形态变化是否发生得太快以至于无法用中性漂变来解释(这表明存在定向选择),或者是否发生得太慢(这表明存在稳定选择)。这些速率测试的先前公式忽略了系统发育成分。本文考虑了几种进化模型,以在速率测试的背景下帮助解释系统发育。对果蝇属粗壮果蝇物种组的几个物种中的九个形态特征进行了稳定选择的MDE速率测试。这些测试可以解释为表明稳定选择可能是在所研究的果蝇物种之间产生观察到的相似性的主要因素。