Chen Huiyu, Liu Xun, Ma Xingming, Wang Qian, Yang Guang, Niu Hongxia, Li Shuaixiang, He Bingzheng, He Shanshan, Dannenberg Arthur M, Zhu Bingdong, Zhang Ying
Department of Immunology, School of Basic Medical Sciences, Lanzhou UniversityLanzhou, China.
Gansu Key Lab of Evidence Based Medicine and Clinical Transfer Medicine & Lanzhou Center for Tuberculosis Research, Lanzhou UniversityLanzhou, China.
Front Microbiol. 2017 May 17;8:842. doi: 10.3389/fmicb.2017.00842. eCollection 2017.
BCG protection is suboptimal and there is significant interest to develop new tuberculosis (TB) vaccines. However, there are significant limitations of the current vaccine evaluation systems in the mouse model. Here, we developed a BCG-challenge rabbit skin model as a new way to evaluate the protective efficacy of selected TB subunit vaccine candidates. Rabbits were immunized with subunit vaccines, including EAMM (ESAT6-Ag85B-MPT64-Mtb8.4), MH (Mtb10.4-HspX), and LT70 (ESAT6-Ag85B-MPT64-Mtb8.4-Rv2626c) three times subcutaneously every 3-weeks and challenged with the attenuated BCG intradermally 6-weeks after last immunization. The immune response induced by the vaccine candidates was measured, the histopathology induced by the BCG challenge was studied, and the number of bacilli in the liquefied caseum was determined. The subunit vaccines generated high antigen-specific IgG antibodies and fastened the liquefaction and healing process, and significantly reduced the viable BCG load. The subunit vaccine LT70 and EAMM-MH reduced BCG bacterial load in comparison to proteins EAMM, MH, Rv2626c, and also BCG itself. The Koch phenomena induced by the LT70 and combination of EAMM-MH were the same as that produced by BCG itself and were more rapid than those induced by the other proteins and the saline controls. The subunit vaccines LT70 and the combination of EAMM-MH showed promising protective efficacy as expected in the rabbit skin model, which can serve as a visual and convenient new model for evaluating TB vaccines.
卡介苗的保护效果并不理想,因此人们对开发新型结核病疫苗有着浓厚兴趣。然而,当前小鼠模型中的疫苗评估系统存在重大局限性。在此,我们开发了一种卡介苗攻击兔皮肤模型,作为评估所选结核病亚单位疫苗候选物保护效力的新方法。将兔子每3周皮下免疫三次亚单位疫苗,包括EAMM(早期分泌抗原靶6-抗原85B-培养滤液蛋白64-结核杆菌8.4)、MH(结核杆菌10.4-热休克蛋白X)和LT70(早期分泌抗原靶6-抗原85B-培养滤液蛋白64-结核杆菌8.4- rv2626c),末次免疫6周后皮内注射减毒卡介苗进行攻击。检测候选疫苗诱导的免疫反应,研究卡介苗攻击诱导的组织病理学变化,并确定液化干酪样物质中的杆菌数量。亚单位疫苗产生了高抗原特异性IgG抗体,加速了液化和愈合过程,并显著降低了活卡介苗载量。与蛋白EAMM、MH、rv2626c以及卡介苗本身相比,亚单位疫苗LT70和EAMM-MH降低了卡介苗细菌载量。LT70以及EAMM-MH组合诱导的科赫现象与卡介苗本身产生的相同,且比其他蛋白和生理盐水对照组诱导的更快。亚单位疫苗LT70以及EAMM-MH组合在兔皮肤模型中显示出预期的良好保护效力,可作为一种直观且便捷的新型结核病疫苗评估模型。