Mitchell Paul, Arthur Wallace
School of Biology, Sunderland Polytechnic, Sunderland, SR1 3SD, UK.
Evolution. 1991 Mar;45(2):307-313. doi: 10.1111/j.1558-5646.1991.tb04405.x.
When Drosophila simulans and Drosophila funebris were cultured together in population cages over many generations, there was a prolonged period of apparently stable coexistence followed by a rapid exclusion of D. funebris. As both species maintained large population sizes in monocultures it follows that the extinctions of D. funebris in the mixed-species cultures must have been caused by D. simulans. The time to extinction of D. funebris ranged from 26 weeks in one cage, to between 40 and 48 weeks in the other five. To test the idea that an evolutionary increase in competitive ability of D. simulans had occurred during the course of its interaction with D. funebris, a single-generation experiment was set up. In this experiment the interspecific competitive ability of a population of D. simulans that had been in competition with D. funebris for 44 weeks was compared to that of a stock population that had had no previous contact with D. funebris. In this experiment both stock and precompeted populations of D. simulans increased the egg-to-adult development time of D. funebris. However, precompeted D. simulans caused a significantly greater increase in the development time of D. funebris than did stock D. simulans. Thus D. simulans had evolved an increase in competitive ability as a result of its interaction with D. funebris. Development time is important because in the population cages the resource bottles-in which the larvae reside-were replaced every three weeks. An increase in development time of D. funebris in the multigeneration experiment similar to that observed in the single-generation experiment would lead to a rapid decrease in adult population size, resulting in the extinction of this species, as was observed to happen.
当拟果蝇和黑腹果蝇在种群笼中共同培养多代时,有一段明显稳定共存的延长时期,随后黑腹果蝇迅速被排除。由于这两个物种在单一培养中都维持着较大的种群规模,因此可以推断,混合物种培养中黑腹果蝇的灭绝一定是由拟果蝇导致的。黑腹果蝇灭绝的时间从一个笼子中的26周,到其他五个笼子中的40至48周不等。为了验证拟果蝇在与黑腹果蝇相互作用过程中竞争能力发生进化增强这一观点,开展了一项单代实验。在该实验中,将与黑腹果蝇竞争了44周的拟果蝇种群的种间竞争能力,与之前从未接触过黑腹果蝇的原种种群进行了比较。在该实验中,拟果蝇的原种种群和经过竞争的种群都延长了黑腹果蝇从卵到成虫的发育时间。然而,经过竞争的拟果蝇比原种拟果蝇导致黑腹果蝇发育时间的延长显著更多。因此,拟果蝇在与黑腹果蝇的相互作用中进化出了更强的竞争能力。发育时间很重要,因为在种群笼中,幼虫所在的资源瓶每三周更换一次。在多代实验中,黑腹果蝇发育时间的延长与单代实验中观察到的情况相似,这将导致成虫种群规模迅速下降,从而导致该物种灭绝,正如实际观察到的那样。