Barr Neil, Vania Diana, Randall Glen, Mulvale Gillian
1 Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University, Canada.
2 DeGroote School of Business, McMaster University, Canada.
J Health Serv Res Policy. 2017 Oct;22(4):250-257. doi: 10.1177/1355819617714292. Epub 2017 Jun 6.
Objectives Information and communication technology is often lauded as the key to enhancing communication among health care providers. However, its impact on interprofessional collaboration is unclear. The objective of this study was to determine the extent to which it improves communication and, subsequently, enhances interprofessional collaboration in chronic disease management. Methods A systematic review of academic literature using two electronic platforms: HealthSTAR and Web of Science (core collection and MEDLINE). To be eligible for inclusion in the review, articles needed to be peer-reviewed; accessible in English and focused on how technology supports, or might support, collaboration (through enhanced communication) in chronic disease management. Studies were assessed for quality and a narrative synthesis conducted. Results The searches identified 289 articles of which six were included in the final analysis (three used qualitative methods, two were descriptive and one used mixed methods). Various forms of information and communication technology were described including electronic health records, online communities/learning resources and telehealth/telecare. Three themes emerged from the studies that may provide insights into how communication that facilitates collaboration in chronic disease management might be enhanced: professional conflict, collective engagement and continuous learning. Conclusions The success of technology in enhancing collaboration for chronic disease management depends upon supporting the social relationships and organization in which the technology will be placed. Decision-makers should take into account and work toward balancing the impact of technology together with the professional and cultural characteristics of health care teams.
目标 信息通信技术常被誉为增强医疗服务提供者之间沟通的关键。然而,其对跨专业协作的影响尚不明晰。本研究的目的是确定其在多大程度上改善沟通,并进而增强慢性病管理中的跨专业协作。方法 使用两个电子平台对学术文献进行系统综述:HealthSTAR和科学网(核心合集及MEDLINE)。要符合纳入综述的条件,文章需经过同行评审;英文可获取且聚焦于技术如何支持或可能支持慢性病管理中的协作(通过增强沟通)。对研究进行质量评估并进行叙述性综合分析。结果 检索到289篇文章,其中6篇纳入最终分析(3篇采用定性方法,2篇为描述性研究,1篇采用混合方法)。描述了各种形式的信息通信技术,包括电子健康记录、在线社区/学习资源以及远程医疗/远程护理。研究中出现了三个主题,可能为如何增强促进慢性病管理中协作的沟通提供见解:专业冲突、集体参与和持续学习。结论 技术在增强慢性病管理协作方面的成功取决于支持技术应用所处的社会关系和组织。决策者应考虑并努力平衡技术的影响以及医疗团队的专业和文化特征。