Ponlawat A, Harwood J F, Putnam J L, Nitatsukprasert C, Pongsiri A, Kijchalao U, Linthicum K J, Kline D L, Clark G G, Obenauer P J, Doud C W, Mccardle P W, Richardson A G, Szumlas D E, Richardson J H
J Am Mosq Control Assoc. 2017 Jun;33(2):116-127. doi: 10.2987/16-6594.1.
Efficacies of a handheld thermal fogger (Patriot™) and a backpack ultra-low volume (ULV) sprayer (Twister™) with combinations of 2 different adulticides (pyrethrin, deltamethrin) and an insect growth regulator (pyriproxyfen) were field-tested and compared for their impact on reducing indoor Aedes aegypti populations in Thailand. The effectiveness of the indoor space sprays was evaluated by sampling the natural Ae. aegypti population in houses and determining their physiological status, by monitoring mortality of sentinel caged mosquitoes (AFRIMS strain) and by assessing larval mortality in laboratory bioassays using water exposed to the spray. A total of 14,742 Ae. aegypti were collected from Biogents Sentinel traps in this study. The combination of ULD® BP-300 (3% pyrethrin) and NyGuard® (10% pyriproxyfen) sprayed either by the Patriot or Twister significantly reduced some Ae. aegypti populations up to 20 days postspray relative to the control clusters. The addition of pyriproxyfen to the adulticide extended how long household mosquito populations were suppressed. In 2 of the 4 products being compared, the Twister resulted in higher mortality of caged mosquitoes compared with the Patriot. However, neither machine was able to achieve high mortality among Ae. aegypti placed in hidden (protected) cages. The larval bioassay results demonstrated that the Twister ULV provided better adult emergence inhibition than the Patriot (thermal fogger), likely due to larger droplet size.
在泰国,对手持式热烟雾机(爱国者™)和背负式超低容量(ULV)喷雾器(龙卷风™)与两种不同杀虫剂(除虫菊酯、溴氰菊酯)及一种昆虫生长调节剂(吡丙醚)的组合进行了实地测试,并比较了它们对减少室内埃及伊蚊种群数量的影响。通过对房屋内自然埃及伊蚊种群进行采样并确定其生理状态、监测哨兵笼养蚊子(AFRIMS品系)的死亡率以及使用暴露于喷雾的水进行实验室生物测定来评估幼虫死亡率,从而评估室内空间喷雾的效果。在本研究中,共从Biogents哨兵诱捕器中收集了14742只埃及伊蚊。与对照群组相比,使用爱国者或龙卷风喷雾器喷洒ULD® BP - 300(3%除虫菊酯)和NyGuard®(10%吡丙醚)的组合在喷雾后长达20天显著减少了一些埃及伊蚊种群数量。在杀虫剂中添加吡丙醚延长了家庭蚊子种群受抑制的时间。在被比较的4种产品中的2种中,龙卷风导致笼养蚊子的死亡率高于爱国者。然而,这两种机器都无法使置于隐藏(受保护)笼子中的埃及伊蚊达到高死亡率。幼虫生物测定结果表明,龙卷风超低容量喷雾器比爱国者(热烟雾机)提供了更好的成虫羽化抑制效果,这可能是由于液滴尺寸更大。