Patrick J M, Wharrad H J, Wilson C G, Birmingham A T
Br J Clin Pharmacol. 1985 Feb;19(2):177-85. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2125.1985.tb02629.x.
The effects on heart rate (HR) and physical activity of 1 week's treatment with three different beta-adrenoceptor antagonists (20 mg betaxolol (Lorex); 160 mg propranolol LA; or 100 mg atenolol daily) have been compared with placebo in a double-blind study of 12 normal men. On the fifth day of each treatment a body-borne tape-recorder was worn during waking hours for recording of ECG and footfall signals. Each record was calibrated in terms of the subject's response to laboratory ergometer exercise, and a computer analysis provided objective indices of physical activity. While on beta-adrenoceptor antagonists the subjects perceived standard exercise as significantly harder than on placebo and reported more side-effects (albeit mild and transient). Ambulatory monitoring of HR showed that subjects spent 13% of their waking day at heart rates below 50 beats min-1 while on propranolol, compared with 1% on placebo and 20% on atenolol and betaxolol. On these latter drugs, the group spent as much as 10% of their waking time with HR below 45 beats min-1. The lowest individual heart-rates recorded were below 35 beats min-1. Objective indices of physical activity, such as the duration of periods spent with heart rates above the HR found at 100 W in the ergometer test, showed no differences between the treatments. This negative finding was confirmed by pedometer step counts over the whole week.
在一项针对12名正常男性的双盲研究中,将三种不同的β-肾上腺素能受体拮抗剂(每日20毫克倍他洛尔(洛尔);160毫克长效普萘洛尔;或100毫克阿替洛尔)治疗1周对心率(HR)和身体活动的影响与安慰剂进行了比较。在每种治疗的第五天,受试者在清醒时间佩戴一个身体携带的磁带录音机,用于记录心电图和脚步声信号。每个记录根据受试者对实验室测力计运动的反应进行校准,计算机分析提供身体活动的客观指标。在服用β-肾上腺素能受体拮抗剂期间,受试者感觉标准运动比服用安慰剂时明显更费力,并报告了更多的副作用(尽管轻微且短暂)。对HR的动态监测显示,服用普萘洛尔时,受试者在清醒日有13%的时间心率低于50次/分钟,而服用安慰剂时为1%,服用阿替洛尔和倍他洛尔时为20%。在服用后两种药物时,该组有多达10%的清醒时间心率低于45次/分钟。记录到的最低个体心率低于35次/分钟。身体活动的客观指标,如在测力计测试中心率高于100瓦时的心率持续时间,在各治疗组之间没有差异。这一阴性结果通过整周的计步器步数得到了证实。