Xu Fanping, Huang Minghua, Jin Yi, Kong Qingzhe, Lei Zhongmin, Wei Xu
Department of Orthopaedics, Beijing Hospital of Traditional Chinese Medicine Affiliated to Capital Medical University, Beijing, China.
Department of Scientific Research, Wangjing hospital, China Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences, Beijing, China.
PLoS One. 2017 Jun 7;12(6):e0178688. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0178688. eCollection 2017.
Primary osteoporosis (POP) has a serious impact on quality of life for middle-aged and elderly, which particularly increase the risk of fracture. We conducted the systematic review to evaluate the effects of moxibustion for POP in randomized controlled trials (RCTs).Eight databases were searched from their inception to July 30, 2016. The RCTs reporting the moxibustion as a monotherapy or in combination with conventional therapy for POP were enrolled. The outcomes might be fracture incidence, quality of life, clinical symptoms, death attributed to osteoporosis, adverse effect, bone mineral density (BMD), and biochemical indicators. Literature selection, data abstraction, quality evaluation, and data analysis were in accordance with Cochrane standards.Thirteen trials including 808 patients were included. Meta-analysis was not conducted because of the obvious clinical or statistical heterogeneity. Limited evidence suggested that moxibustion plus anti-osteoporosis medicine might be more effective in relieving the pain (visual analogue scale scores average changed 2 scores between groups, 4 trials), increasing the BMD of femoral neck (average changed 0.4 g/cm2 between groups, 3 trials), and improving the level of bone gla protein, osteoprotegerin and bone alkaline phosphatase (2 trials) compared with anti-osteoporosis medicine alone. However, the quality of previous studies was evaluated as generally poor. The safety evidence of moxibustion was still insufficient. Due to the paucity of high-quality studies, there was no definite conclusion about the efficacy and safety of moxibustion treating POP although parts of positive results were presented. Future research should pay attention to the dose-response relation and fracture incidence of moxibustion for POP.
原发性骨质疏松症(POP)对中老年人群的生活质量有严重影响,尤其会增加骨折风险。我们进行了一项系统评价,以评估随机对照试验(RCT)中艾灸治疗POP的效果。检索了8个数据库,检索时间从建库至2016年7月30日。纳入将艾灸作为单一疗法或与传统疗法联合用于治疗POP的RCT。结局指标可能包括骨折发生率、生活质量、临床症状、骨质疏松所致死亡、不良反应、骨密度(BMD)和生化指标。文献筛选、数据提取、质量评估和数据分析均符合Cochrane标准。共纳入13项试验,涉及808例患者。由于存在明显的临床或统计学异质性,未进行荟萃分析。有限的证据表明,与单纯抗骨质疏松药物相比,艾灸联合抗骨质疏松药物在缓解疼痛(视觉模拟评分两组平均变化2分,4项试验)-、增加股骨颈骨密度(两组平均变化0.4g/cm²,3项试验)以及改善骨钙素、骨保护素和骨碱性磷酸酶水平(2项试验)方面可能更有效。然而,既往研究质量总体评估较差。艾灸的安全性证据仍不足。由于高质量研究较少,尽管呈现了部分阳性结果,但关于艾灸治疗POP的疗效和安全性尚无明确结论。未来研究应关注艾灸治疗POP的剂量反应关系和骨折发生率。