O'Shaughnessy S M
Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, Dublin, Ireland.
College of Anaesthetists of Ireland, Dublin, Ireland.
Ir J Med Sci. 2018 Feb;187(1):207-213. doi: 10.1007/s11845-017-1637-5. Epub 2017 Jun 8.
The purpose of this study is to introduce peer teaching of communication skills to first-year anaesthesia trainees in Ireland and to evaluate their perception of this teaching modality.
Seventy-nine first-year anaesthesia trainees participated in a novel peer-led communication skills programme over a 2-year period (Y1, Y2). A Likert scaling questionnaire was developed to explore trainee perception of the peer teaching programme.
Of the 79 respondents (36 in Y1 and 43 in Y2), 99% either agreed or strongly agreed that the peer teachers were successful in their role. Ninety-two percent requested formal peer teaching in other areas of training. The trainees regarded a peer teacher as an appropriate information provider (92%), role model (88%), planner (88%) and facilitator (94%), but less so as an assessor (70%). The most consistently stated strength of peer teaching was the relatability of peer teachers with their lack of experience cited as the main weakness. Eighty percent of participants preferred peer teaching to regular expert teaching.
This study highlights the positive attitudes of first-year anaesthesia trainees towards a novel peer teaching programme in communication skills. This author recommends that peer teaching is further developed within postgraduate medical programmes to maximise learning for trainees in the student and teacher roles and to redistribute the teaching burden within clinical departments.
本研究旨在向爱尔兰的一年级麻醉实习医生介绍沟通技能的同伴教学,并评估他们对这种教学方式的看法。
79名一年级麻醉实习医生在两年时间里(Y1、Y2)参与了一项由同伴主导的新型沟通技能培训项目。开发了一份李克特量表问卷,以探究实习医生对同伴教学项目的看法。
在79名受访者中(Y1组36人,Y2组43人),99%的人同意或强烈同意同伴教师胜任其职。92%的人要求在其他培训领域开展正式的同伴教学。实习医生认为同伴教师是合适的信息提供者(92%)、榜样(88%)、规划者(88%)和促进者(94%),但作为评估者则认可度较低(70%)。同伴教学最常被提及的优点是同伴教师的亲和力,而缺乏经验被认为是主要缺点。80%的参与者更喜欢同伴教学而非常规的专家教学。
本研究凸显了一年级麻醉实习医生对新型沟通技能同伴教学项目的积极态度。作者建议在研究生医学项目中进一步发展同伴教学,以最大限度地促进实习医生在学生和教师角色中的学习,并在临床科室重新分配教学负担。