Filippiadou Magdalini, Kouvelas Dimitrios, Garyfallos Georgios, Tsakiridis Ioannis, Tzachanis Dimitrios, Spachos Dimitrios, Papazisis Georgios
Department of Clinical Pharmacology, Faculty of Medicine, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Greece.
2nd University Department of Psychiatry, Psychiatric Hospital of Thessaloniki, Greece.
Ann Med Surg (Lond). 2017 May 29;19:23-28. doi: 10.1016/j.amsu.2017.05.013. eCollection 2017 Jul.
Medical students are targeted by the pharmaceutical industry and are exposed to their marketing strategies even in the preclinical years of study. The marketing strategies used by pharmaceutical companies with physicians are also applied to students, affecting their future prescribing behaviour, and include low-cost non-educational gifts, travel expenses and conferences registration fees. In Greece, there are no national or institutional regulations and guidelines concerning drug company-medical student interactions. This study is the first time this estimate has been made in Greece and assessed a) the interactions between pharmaceutical companies and medical students, and b) students' attitudes towards pharmaceutical marketing.
A sampling of undergraduate medical students completed an anonymous, self-administered, web-based survey. The first part of the survey investigated the interaction between the students and pharmaceutical companies; the possible answers were the binomial variables 'yes' or 'no'. The second part assessed the students' opinions of pharmaceutical company marketing and the answer options were 'agree', 'don't know/don't answer' and 'disagree'.
The survey was completed by 412 undergraduate medical students (mean age 22 ± 2.2 years, 52.7% were women); the overall response rate was 58.9%. Although the majority did not consider accepting gifts and meals from drug companies as ethical, most of them (59%) had accepted meals and low-cost non-educational gifts, especially the clinical-level students. Further, 52,6% of the students did not believe that accepting gifts from pharmaceutical companies would affect their own prescription behaviour, whereas surprisingly they held the opposite opinion of their classmates. The vast majority (85.9%) agreed that sponsored lectures were biased in favour of a company's products; however, 47.6% agreed that promotional material is useful for learning about new medications and 34.5% believed that medical schools should allow drug company representatives to interact with students.
Our results suggest that medical students in Greece are notably exposed to pharmaceutical industry marketing and their conflicting answers demonstrate that they are inadequately prepared for this interaction. Interventions are needed so that students are prepared and able to manage these interactions critically.
医学生是制药行业的目标群体,甚至在临床前学习阶段就会接触到制药行业的营销策略。制药公司针对医生采用的营销策略同样也用于学生,这会影响他们未来的处方行为,这些策略包括低成本的非教育性礼品、差旅费和会议注册费。在希腊,没有关于制药公司与医学生互动的国家或机构法规及指导方针。本研究首次在希腊进行此类评估,旨在评估:a)制药公司与医学生之间的互动;b)学生对制药营销的态度。
对本科医学生进行抽样,让他们完成一份匿名的、基于网络的自填式调查问卷。调查问卷的第一部分调查学生与制药公司之间的互动;可能的答案为二项变量“是”或“否”。第二部分评估学生对制药公司营销的看法,答案选项为“同意”“不知道/不回答”和“不同意”。
412名本科医学生完成了调查(平均年龄22±2.2岁,52.7%为女性);总体回复率为58.9%。尽管大多数人认为接受制药公司的礼品和餐食不符合道德规范,但他们中的大多数人(59%)都接受过餐食和低成本的非教育性礼品,尤其是临床阶段的学生。此外,52.6%的学生认为接受制药公司的礼品不会影响自己的处方行为,然而令人惊讶的是,他们对同学的看法却相反。绝大多数人(85.9%)认为赞助讲座偏向于某公司的产品;然而,47.6%的人认为促销材料对了解新药有用,3 .5%的人认为医学院应该允许制药公司代表与学生互动。
我们的研究结果表明,希腊的医学生明显受到制药行业营销的影响,他们相互矛盾的回答表明他们对这种互动准备不足。需要采取干预措施,使学生做好准备并能够批判性地应对这些互动。