Baghbadorani Sahar Torki, Ehsani Mohammad Reza, Mirlohi Maryam, Ezzatpanah Hamid, Azadbakht Leila, Babashahi Mina
Department of Food Science and Technology, Faculty of Agriculture and Natural Resources, Islamic Azad University, Science and Research Branch, Tehran, Iran.
Department of Food Technology, Food Security Research Center, School of Nutrition and Food Science, Isfahan University of Medical Sciences, Isfahan, Iran.
Adv Biomed Res. 2017 May 29;6:62. doi: 10.4103/2277-9175.207150. eCollection 2017.
Due to the recent emerging information on the antioxidant properties of soy products, substitution of soy milk for milk in the diet has been proposed by some nutritionists. We aimed to compare four distinct antioxidant measuring methods in the evaluation of antioxidant properties of industrial ultra-high temperature (UHT) milk, UHT soy milk, and their fermented products by A7.
Ascorbate auto-oxidation inhibition assay, 2,2-diphenyl-1-picryl-hydrazyl-hydrate (DPPH) free radical scavenging method, hydrogen peroxide neutralization assay and reducing activity test were compared for the homogeneity and accuracy of the results.
The results obtained by the four tested methods did not completely match with each other. The results of the DPPH assay and the reducing activity were more coordinated than the other methods. By the use of these methods, the antioxidant capability of UHT soy milk was measured more than UHT milk (33.51 ± 6.00% and 945 ± 56 μM cysteine compared to 8.70 ± 3.20% and 795 ± 82 μM cysteine). The negative effect of fermentation on the antioxidant potential of UHT soy milk was revealed as ascorbate auto-oxidation inhibition assay, DPPH method and reducing activity tests ended to approximately 52%, 58%, and 80% reduction in antioxidant potential of UHT soy milk, respectively.
The antioxidative properties of UHT soy milk could not be solely due to its phenolic components. Peptides and amino acids derived from thermal processing in soy milk probably have a main role in its antioxidant activity, which should be studied in the future.
由于近期出现了有关大豆制品抗氧化特性的信息,一些营养学家提议在饮食中用豆浆替代牛奶。我们旨在比较四种不同的抗氧化剂测量方法,以评估工业超高温(UHT)牛奶、UHT豆浆及其发酵产品的抗氧化特性。
比较了抗坏血酸自氧化抑制试验、2,2-二苯基-1-苦基肼基水合物(DPPH)自由基清除法、过氧化氢中和试验和还原活性测试结果的同质性和准确性。
四种测试方法得到的结果并不完全一致。DPPH试验和还原活性的结果比其他方法更具协调性。通过使用这些方法,测得UHT豆浆的抗氧化能力高于UHT牛奶(分别为33.51±6.00%和945±56μM半胱氨酸,而UHT牛奶为8.70±3.20%和795±82μM半胱氨酸)。抗坏血酸自氧化抑制试验、DPPH法和还原活性测试结果显示,发酵对UHT豆浆抗氧化潜力有负面影响,UHT豆浆的抗氧化潜力分别降低了约52%、58%和80%。
UHT豆浆的抗氧化特性不能仅归因于其酚类成分。豆浆热加工产生的肽和氨基酸可能在其抗氧化活性中起主要作用,这一点有待未来研究。