Department of Geography and Resource Development, University of Ghana, Box Lg 59, Legon, Accra, Ghana.
Department of Geography, Environment, & Society, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN 55455, U.S.A.
Sci Total Environ. 2017 Dec 1;601-602:1566-1574. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2017.05.283. Epub 2017 Jun 9.
E-waste recycling remains a major source of livelihood for many urban poor in developing countries, but this economic activity is fraught with significant environmental health risk. Yet, human exposure to the toxic elements associated with e-waste activities remains understudied and not evidently understood. This study investigates the impact of informal e-waste processing on the blood lead levels (BLLs) of e-waste workers and non-e-waste workers (mainly females working in activities that serve the Agbogbloshie e-waste site), and relates their lead exposure to socio-demographic and occupational characteristics. A total of 128 blood samples were analysed for lead levels. Surprisingly, the mean BLL (3.54μg/dL) of non-e-waste workers was slightly higher than that of e-waste workers (3.49μg/dL), although higher BLLs ranges were found among e-waste workers (0.50-18.80μg/dL) than non-e-waste workers (0.30-8.20μg/dL). Workers who engaged in e-waste burning tended to have the highest BLLs. In general, the BLLs are within the ABLES/US CDC reference level of 5μg/dL, although 12.3% of the workers have elevated BLLs, i.e. BLL ≥5μg/dL. The study concludes that the impact of e-waste recycling is not limited to workers alone. Traders and residents within the Agbogbloshie enclave are equally at risk through a range of environmental vectors. This calls for increased public awareness about the effects of human exposure to lead and other toxic elements from e-waste recycling. A key contribution is that government and stakeholder projects for safe e-waste infrastructure should disaggregate the e-waste value chain, recognize differential risk and resist one-size-fits-all strategies.
电子废物回收仍然是许多发展中国家城市贫困人口的主要生计来源,但这种经济活动充满了重大的环境健康风险。然而,人类接触与电子废物活动相关的有毒元素的情况仍未得到充分研究,也未得到明确理解。本研究调查了非正式电子废物处理对电子废物工人和非电子废物工人(主要是在为阿格博格布洛西电子废物场服务的活动中工作的女性)的血液铅水平(BLL)的影响,并将其铅暴露与社会人口统计学和职业特征联系起来。总共分析了 128 份血样的铅含量。令人惊讶的是,非电子废物工人的平均 BLL(3.54μg/dL)略高于电子废物工人(3.49μg/dL),尽管电子废物工人的 BLL 范围更高(0.50-18.80μg/dL),而非电子废物工人的 BLL 范围较低(0.30-8.20μg/dL)。从事电子废物燃烧的工人往往具有最高的 BLL。总的来说,BLL 在 ABLES/USCDC 的参考水平 5μg/dL 以内,尽管 12.3%的工人 BLL 升高,即 BLL≥5μg/dL。该研究得出的结论是,电子废物回收的影响不仅限于工人。阿格博格布洛西飞地内的贸易商和居民通过一系列环境媒介同样面临风险。这就需要提高公众对人类接触电子废物回收产生的铅和其他有毒元素的影响的认识。一个重要的贡献是,政府和利益攸关方关于安全电子废物基础设施的项目应分解电子废物价值链,认识到不同的风险,并抵制一刀切的策略。