Mohsin Mir, Zargar Haroon Rashid, Wani Adil Hafeez, Zaroo Mohammad Inam, Baba Peerzada Umar Farooq, Bashir Sheikh Adil, Rasool Altaf, Bijli Akram Hussain
Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, SKIMS, Srinagar, Jammu and Kashmir, India.
Indian J Plast Surg. 2017 Jan-Apr;50(1):43-49. doi: 10.4103/ijps.IJPS_196_16.
Split-thickness skin grafting (STSG) is a time-tested technique in wound cover, but many factors lead to suboptimal graft take. Role of custom-made negative-pressure wound therapy (NPWT) is compared with conventional dress in the integration of STSG and its cost is compared with widely used commercially available NPWT.
This is a parallel group randomised control study. Block randomisation of 100 patients into one of the two groups (NPWT vs. non-NPWT; 50 patients each) was done. Graft take/loss, length of hospital stay post-grafting, need for regrafting and cost of custom-made negative pressure wound therapy (NPWT) dressings as compared to widely used commercially available NPWT were assessed.
Mean graft take in the NPWT group was 99.74% ± 0.73% compared to 88.52% ± 9.47% in the non-NPWT group ( = 0.004). None of the patients in the NPWT group required second coverage procedure as opposed to six cases in the non-NPWT group ( = 0.035). All the patients in the NPWT group were discharged within 4-9 days from the day of grafting. No major complication was encountered with the use of custom-made NPWT. Custom-made NPWT dressings were found to be 22 times cheaper than the widely used commercially available NPWT.
Custom-made NPWT is a safe, simple and effective technique in the integration of STSG as compared to the conventional dressings. We have been able to reduce the financial burden on the patients as well as the hospital significantly while achieving results at par with other studies which have used commercially available NPWT.
中厚皮片移植(STSG)是一种经过时间考验的伤口覆盖技术,但许多因素会导致移植皮片的成活率不理想。将定制负压伤口治疗(NPWT)与传统敷料在中厚皮片移植融合中的作用进行比较,并将其成本与广泛使用的市售NPWT进行比较。
这是一项平行组随机对照研究。将100例患者进行区组随机化,分为两组之一(NPWT组与非NPWT组;每组50例患者)。评估移植皮片的成活/丢失情况、移植后住院时间、再次移植的需求以及与广泛使用的市售NPWT相比,定制负压伤口治疗(NPWT)敷料的成本。
NPWT组的平均移植皮片成活率为99.74%±0.73%,而非NPWT组为88.52%±9.47%(P = 0.004)。NPWT组没有患者需要二次覆盖手术,而非NPWT组有6例(P = 0.035)。NPWT组的所有患者在移植当天起4 - 9天内出院。使用定制NPWT未出现重大并发症。发现定制NPWT敷料比广泛使用的市售NPWT便宜22倍。
与传统敷料相比,定制NPWT在中厚皮片移植融合中是一种安全、简单且有效的技术。我们在取得与其他使用市售NPWT的研究相当的结果的同时,显著减轻了患者和医院的经济负担。