Wolff Djoeke, van Melle Joost P, Bartelds Beatrijs, Ridderbos Floris-Jan S, Eshuis Graziella, van Stratum Elisabeth B H J, Recinos Salvador J, Willemse Brigitte W M, Hillege Hans, Willems Tineke P, Ebels Tjark, Berger Rolf M F
Center for Congenital Heart Diseases, Department of Pediatric Cardiology, University Medical Center Groningen, University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands.
Department of Cardiology, University Medical Center Groningen, University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands.
Am J Cardiol. 2017 Aug 1;120(3):461-466. doi: 10.1016/j.amjcard.2017.05.005. Epub 2017 May 11.
The unique, unphysiological Fontan circulation is associated with an impaired functional status of the patients that is suggested to deteriorate over time. Unfortunately, previous studies did not integrate both pulmonary and cardiac determinants of functional status. In addition, a comparison with the natural decrease in exercise capacity in healthy subjects (in both children and adults) is lacking. This single-center study aims to investigate the functional status in a cohort of Fontan patients in relation to time since Fontan completion and to identify its determinants, including cardiac characteristics and pulmonary characteristics. Eighty-five consecutive Fontan patients ≥10 years who performed adequate cardiopulmonary exercise testing (respiratory exchange ratio >1.01) were included. Mean time since Fontan completion was 15 ± 9 years (range 2 to 37 years). New York Heart Association functional class was I in 36 patients (42%), II in 41 patients (48%), and III in 8 patients (9%). Peak oxygen uptake during exercise (VO index) was 25.7 ± 7.9 ml/min/m (58 ± 14% of predicted). New York Heart Association functional class and peak VO index both correlated with time since the Fontan operation; however, peak VO as percentage of predicted (VO(pred)) did not. In multivariate analyses, peak VO(pred) was independently associated with maximum heart rate, oxygen pulse at peak exercise, and forced expiratory volume in 1 second (R = 0.579) but not with cardiac output in rest. In conclusion, the present data suggest that functional status in Fontan patients is impaired already shortly after Fontan completion, whereas its subsequent deterioration seems to follow the natural decline of aging. Furthermore, functional status in Fontan patients correlates with pulmonary function and cardiac functional parameters during exercise but not with conventional cardiac measurements at rest.
独特的、非生理性的Fontan循环与患者功能状态受损有关,且功能状态可能会随时间推移而恶化。遗憾的是,既往研究未综合考虑功能状态的肺部和心脏决定因素。此外,缺乏与健康受试者(儿童和成人)运动能力自然下降情况的比较。这项单中心研究旨在调查一组Fontan术后患者的功能状态与Fontan手术完成后的时间关系,并确定其决定因素,包括心脏特征和肺部特征。纳入了85例年龄≥10岁、进行了充分心肺运动试验(呼吸交换率>1.01)的连续Fontan患者。Fontan手术完成后的平均时间为15±9年(范围2至37年)。纽约心脏协会心功能分级为I级的患者有36例(42%),II级的有41例(48%),III级的有8例(9%)。运动时的峰值摄氧量(VO₂指数)为25.7±7.9 ml/min/m²(为预测值的58±14%)。纽约心脏协会心功能分级和峰值VO₂指数均与Fontan手术后的时间相关;然而,峰值VO₂占预测值的百分比(VO₂(pred))与时间无关。在多变量分析中,峰值VO₂(pred)与最大心率、运动峰值时的氧脉搏以及第1秒用力呼气量独立相关(R = 0.579),但与静息心输出量无关。总之,目前的数据表明,Fontan患者在Fontan手术完成后不久功能状态就已受损,而其随后的恶化似乎遵循衰老的自然下降趋势。此外,Fontan患者的功能状态与运动时的肺功能和心脏功能参数相关,但与静息时的传统心脏测量值无关。