van den Berg Esther, Jiskoot Lize C, Grosveld Mariëlle J H, van Swieten John C, Papma Janne M
Alzheimer Center and Department of Neurology, Erasmus University Medical Center, Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
Dement Geriatr Cogn Disord. 2017;44(1-2):35-44. doi: 10.1159/000477538. Epub 2017 Jun 17.
BACKGROUND/AIMS: Verbal fluency is impaired in patients with frontotemporal dementia (FTD) and primary progressive aphasia (PPA). This study explored qualitative differences in verbal fluency (clustering of words, switching between strategies) between FTD and PPA variants.
Twenty-nine patients with behavioral variant FTD (bvFTD) and 50 with PPA (13 nonfluent/agrammatic, 14 semantic, and 23 logopenic) performed a semantic and letter fluency task. Clustering (number of multiword strings) and switching (number of transitions between clustered and nonclustered words) were recorded by two independent raters. Between-group differences, associations with memory, language, and executive functioning, and longitudinal change (subsample) in clustering and switching were examined.
Interrater reliability was high (median 0.98). PPA patients generated (a) smaller (number of) clusters on semantic and letter fluency than bvFTD patients (p < 0.05). Semantic variant patients used more switches than nonfluent/agrammatic or logopenic variant patients (p < 0.05). Clustering in semantic fluency was significantly associated with memory and language (range standardized regression coefficients 0.24-0.38). Switching in letter fluency was associated with executive functioning (0.32-0.35).
Clustering and switching in verbal fluency differed between patients with subtypes of FTD and PPA. Qualitative aspects of verbal fluency provide additional information on verbal ability and executive control which can be used for clinically diagnostic purposes.
背景/目的:额颞叶痴呆(FTD)和原发性进行性失语(PPA)患者存在言语流畅性受损的情况。本研究探讨了FTD和PPA各亚型在言语流畅性(词语聚类、策略转换)方面的质性差异。
29例行为变异型FTD(bvFTD)患者和50例PPA患者(13例非流畅性/语法缺失型、14例语义型和23例音韵性失写型)进行了语义和字母流畅性任务。由两名独立评分者记录聚类(多词串数量)和转换(聚类词与非聚类词之间的转换数量)情况。研究了组间差异、与记忆、语言和执行功能的关联以及聚类和转换的纵向变化(子样本)。
评分者间信度较高(中位数为0.98)。PPA患者在语义和字母流畅性任务中生成的聚类(数量)比bvFTD患者小(p<0.05)。语义变异型患者比非流畅性/语法缺失型或音韵性失写型变异型患者使用更多的转换(p<0.05)。语义流畅性中的聚类与记忆和语言显著相关(标准化回归系数范围为0.24 - 0.38)。字母流畅性中的转换与执行功能相关(0.32 - 0.35)。
FTD和PPA各亚型患者在言语流畅性的聚类和转换方面存在差异。言语流畅性的质性方面为言语能力和执行控制提供了额外信息,可用于临床诊断。