Faghihi Seyed Aliakbar, Khankeh Hamid Reza, Hosseini Seyed Jalil, Soltani Arabshahi Seyed Kamran, Faghih Zahra, Shirazi Mandana
Department of Medical Education, Iran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Department of Health in Emergency & Disaster, University of Social Welfare and Rehabilitation Sciences, Tehran, Iran, & Department of Clinical Sciences and Education, Karolinska Institute, Stockholm, Sweden.
Med J Islam Repub Iran. 2017 Jan 26;31:6. doi: 10.18869/mjiri.31.6. eCollection 2017.
Traditional approaches in Continuing Medical Education (CME) appear to be ineffective in any improvement of the patients' care, reducing the medical errors, and/or altering physicians' behaviors. However, they are still executed by the CME providers, and are popular among the majority of the physicians. In this study, we aimed to explore the parameters involved in the degree of effectiveness of CME program in Iran. In this study, 31 participants, consisting of general practitioners, CME experts and providers were recruited to participate in in-depth interviews and field observations concerning experiences with CME. Application was made of the qualitative paradigm along with the qualitative content analysis, using grounded theory data analysis methodology (constant comparative analysis). Based on the participants' experiences, the insufficient consistency between the training program contents and the demands of GPs, in addition to the non-beneficiary programs for the physicians and the non-comprehensive educational designs, created a negative attitude to the continuing education among physicians. This could be defined by an unrealistic continuing education program, which is the main theme here. Impracticable continuing education has created a negative attitude toward the CME programs among physicians so much that they consider these programs less important, resulting in attending the said programs without any specific aim: they dodge absenteeism just to get the credit points. Evidently, promoting CME programs to improve the performance of the physicians requires factual needs assessment over and above adaptation of the contents to the physicians' performance.
继续医学教育(CME)中的传统方法似乎在改善患者护理、减少医疗差错和/或改变医生行为方面毫无成效。然而,这些方法仍由继续医学教育提供者执行,并且在大多数医生中很受欢迎。在本研究中,我们旨在探索伊朗继续医学教育项目有效性程度所涉及的参数。在这项研究中,招募了31名参与者,包括全科医生、继续医学教育专家和提供者,参与关于继续医学教育经历的深入访谈和实地观察。采用定性范式以及定性内容分析,并运用扎根理论数据分析方法(持续比较分析)。基于参与者的经验,培训项目内容与全科医生需求之间缺乏一致性,再加上对医生无益处的项目以及不全面的教育设计,使医生对继续教育产生了消极态度。这可以由一个不切实际的继续教育项目来定义,这是这里的主要主题。不切实际的继续教育在医生中对继续医学教育项目产生了如此消极的态度,以至于他们认为这些项目不太重要,导致参加这些项目没有任何特定目的:他们只是为了获得学分而逃避缺勤。显然,推广继续医学教育项目以提高医生的表现,除了使内容适应医生的表现之外,还需要进行实际的需求评估。