Clarke A K, Kobagi N, Yoon M N
School of Dentistry, Faculty of Medicine and Dentistry, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada.
Int J Dent Hyg. 2018 May;16(2):e38-e45. doi: 10.1111/idh.12295. Epub 2017 Jun 23.
This study investigates whether dental hygienists are routinely conducting oral cancer screenings (OCSs) as per their professional capability and responsibility. Factors that may mediate provision of OCSs, and ability to discuss sensitive topics with patients, are also examined.
A pretested online questionnaire was sent via national and provincial regulatory bodies to target practicing registered dental hygienists across Canada. Analysis was conducted using statistical software.
Results of 256 surveys were analysed. Sixty-four per cent of dental hygienists listed an OCS as part of their regular process of care. Except for the initial examination, respondents were significantly more likely to report being responsible for the OCS than the dentist, P<.001. On average, intraoral components are inspected at higher frequencies (96%) than extraoral components (73%). Confidence in OCS technique was high (70%). The majority felt prepared by their education to conduct OCSs (60%), but those with a bachelor's degree felt more prepared than those with a diploma, P=.005. The average time to conduct an OCS is 4.09 minutes, with most agreeing there is sufficient time in an appointment (57%). Only 37% felt their education prepared them to discuss sensitive topics, level of education had no effect, P>.05. Only 43% of respondents felt confident in their human papillomavirus (HPV) knowledge and comfortable discussing HPV risk factors with patients.
Dental hygienists in this study are regularly conducting OCSs; however, they lack comfort discussing sensitive topics such as transmission of oral HPV, and screenings may not be fully comprehensive.
本研究调查牙科保健员是否按照其专业能力和职责常规开展口腔癌筛查(OCS)。还研究了可能影响OCS实施以及与患者讨论敏感话题能力的因素。
通过国家和省级监管机构向加拿大各地执业的注册牙科保健员发送一份经过预测试的在线问卷。使用统计软件进行分析。
对256份调查问卷的结果进行了分析。64%的牙科保健员将OCS列为其常规护理流程的一部分。除初次检查外,与牙医相比,受访者报告负责OCS的可能性显著更高,P<0.001。平均而言,口腔内组件的检查频率(96%)高于口腔外组件(73%)。对OCS技术的信心较高(70%)。大多数人认为自己所受教育使他们有能力进行OCS(60%),但拥有学士学位的人比拥有文凭的人感觉准备更充分,P = 0.005。进行一次OCS的平均时间为4.09分钟,大多数人认为预约时有足够时间(57%)。只有37%的人认为自己所受教育使他们有能力讨论敏感话题,教育程度对此没有影响,P>0.05。只有43%的受访者对自己的人乳头瘤病毒(HPV)知识有信心,并且愿意与患者讨论HPV风险因素。
本研究中的牙科保健员定期进行OCS;然而,他们在讨论诸如口腔HPV传播等敏感话题时缺乏信心,并且筛查可能并不完全全面。