Zhang Qiong, Borst Jelmer P, Kass Robert E, Anderson John R
Machine Learning Department, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
Center for the Neural Basis of Cognition, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
Hum Brain Mapp. 2017 Sep;38(9):4287-4301. doi: 10.1002/hbm.23689. Epub 2017 Jun 23.
Pooling neural imaging data across subjects requires aligning recordings from different subjects. In magnetoencephalography (MEG) recordings, sensors across subjects are poorly correlated both because of differences in the exact location of the sensors, and structural and functional differences in the brains. It is possible to achieve alignment by assuming that the same regions of different brains correspond across subjects. However, this relies on both the assumption that brain anatomy and function are well correlated, and the strong assumptions that go into solving the under-determined inverse problem given the high-dimensional source space. In this article, we investigated an alternative method that bypasses source-localization. Instead, it analyzes the sensor recordings themselves and aligns their temporal signatures across subjects. We used a multivariate approach, multiset canonical correlation analysis (M-CCA), to transform individual subject data to a low-dimensional common representational space. We evaluated the robustness of this approach over a synthetic dataset, by examining the effect of different factors that add to the noise and individual differences in the data. On an MEG dataset, we demonstrated that M-CCA performs better than a method that assumes perfect sensor correspondence and a method that applies source localization. Last, we described how the standard M-CCA algorithm could be further improved with a regularization term that incorporates spatial sensor information. Hum Brain Mapp 38:4287-4301, 2017. © 2017 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
跨受试者合并神经成像数据需要对来自不同受试者的记录进行对齐。在脑磁图(MEG)记录中,由于传感器的确切位置不同以及大脑的结构和功能差异,不同受试者之间的传感器相关性很差。通过假设不同大脑的相同区域在受试者之间相对应,可以实现对齐。然而,这既依赖于大脑解剖结构和功能具有良好相关性的假设,也依赖于在给定高维源空间的情况下解决欠定逆问题时所采用的强假设。在本文中,我们研究了一种绕过源定位的替代方法。相反,它分析传感器记录本身,并在受试者之间对齐其时间特征。我们使用了一种多变量方法,即多集典型相关分析(M-CCA),将个体受试者数据转换到一个低维公共表示空间。我们通过检查添加到数据中的不同噪声因素和个体差异的影响,在一个合成数据集上评估了这种方法的稳健性。在一个MEG数据集上,我们证明了M-CCA比假设传感器完全对应和应用源定位的方法表现更好。最后,我们描述了如何使用包含空间传感器信息的正则化项进一步改进标准的M-CCA算法。《人类大脑图谱》38:4287 - 4301,2017年。© 2017威利期刊公司。