Berl Madison M, Smith Mary Lou, Bulteau Christine
Children's National Health System, Division of Pediatric Neuropsychology, Washington, DC, George Washington University, Washington, DC, USA.
Department of Psychology, University of Toronto Mississauga, Mississauga, Neurosciences and Mental Health Program, the Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto, Canada.
Epileptic Disord. 2017 Jun 1;19(2):166-177. doi: 10.1684/epd.2017.0908.
To determine the extent to which specific neuropsychological measures are in common use around the world for the assessment of children who are candidates for epilepsy surgery. As part of the work of the International League Against Epilepsy Pediatric Surgical Task Force, a survey was developed and distributed online. The survey consisted of questions related to demographics, training experience, general practice, and specific measures used and at what frequency. Seventy-eight clinicians with an average of 13.5 years of experience from 19 countries responded to the survey; 69% were English-speaking. Pre- and post-neuropsychological evaluations were conducted with a majority of children undergoing surgical resection for epilepsy. There was high consistency (>90%) among the domains evaluated, while consistency rate among specific measures was more variable (range: 0-100%). Consistency rates were also lower among respondents in non-English-speaking countries. For English-speaking respondents, at least one measure within each domain was used by a majority (>75%) of clinicians; 19 specific measures met this criterion. There is consensus of measures used in neuropsychological studies of pediatric epilepsy patients which provides a basis for determining which measures to include in establishing a collaborative data repository to study surgical outcomes of pediatric epilepsy. Challenges include selecting measures that promote collaboration with centers in non-English-speaking countries and providing data from children under age 5.
确定世界各地在评估癫痫手术候选儿童时常用的特定神经心理学测量方法的使用程度。作为国际抗癫痫联盟儿科手术特别工作组工作的一部分,开展了一项在线调查并进行了分发。该调查包括与人口统计学、培训经验、一般实践以及所使用的特定测量方法及其使用频率相关的问题。来自19个国家的78名平均有13.5年经验的临床医生回复了该调查;69%为说英语的医生。大多数接受癫痫手术切除的儿童都进行了术前和术后神经心理学评估。在评估的领域之间存在高度一致性(>90%),而特定测量方法之间的一致性率变化更大(范围:0 - 100%)。非英语国家的受访者之间的一致性率也较低。对于说英语的受访者,每个领域中至少有一种测量方法被大多数(>75%)临床医生使用;19种特定测量方法符合这一标准。在儿科癫痫患者神经心理学研究中使用的测量方法存在共识,这为确定在建立合作数据存储库以研究儿科癫痫手术结果时应纳入哪些测量方法提供了基础。挑战包括选择能够促进与非英语国家中心合作的测量方法以及提供5岁以下儿童的数据。