Department of Neurology, King Edward Memorial Hospital, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India.
Department of Neurology, Zydus Hospital & Smt. B. K. Shah Medical Institute and Research Center, Sumandeep Vidyapeeth, Vadodara, Gujarat, India.
Epilepsia Open. 2024 Oct;9(5):1670-1684. doi: 10.1002/epi4.13005. Epub 2024 Jul 16.
Neuropsychology plays an important role in optimizing epilepsy management, but there are no practice guidelines for low- and middle-income countries with emerging services. The National Epilepsy Surgery Support Activity Network (NESSAN), a national working group that supports and optimizes epilepsy surgery programs in India, explored the present status of pre- and post epilepsy surgery neuropsychological assessment practices across India as an initial step in developing national evidence-based test guidelines. An online survey was conducted using two questionnaires, one for neurologists and the second for neuropsychologists and speech-language pathologists working in epilepsy surgery centers. The questions to neurologists covered the setting, description, and nature of the neuropsychology services provided for adults and children as part of the epilepsy surgery program, and their perceptions about the importance and indications for neuropsychological assessment in epilepsy surgery. The questions to neuropsychologists inquired about their qualifications and training, pre- and postsurgical assessment procedures, and domain-specific cognitive tests and scales for mood, quality of life, and language evaluations. Forty-three centers responded, and neuropsychology services were available at three fourth of the centers, but a dedicated full-time neuropsychologist was available in only 16% of centers. Ninety percent of the neurologists considered neuropsychological evaluation an indispensable part of presurgical evaluation. However, only a few of them believed that the results influenced their decision about the extent of resection and ruling against surgery. The survey found considerable heterogeneity in terms of qualifications and training of neuropsychologists, evaluation procedures, test protocols, and normative data that will need to be harmonized to ensure uniform practice across the country. We believe that the results from this survey provide a road map for implementing measures to minimize existing inadequacies and harmonize neuropsychology services in India and as well as in other countries with emerging neuropsychology services. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: Neuropsychological assessment is an integral part of the pre- and post epilepsy surgery evaluations. In India, the National Epilepsy Surgery Support Activity Network (NESSAN), a body of multidisciplinary professionals, conducted a survey to examine existing neuropsychology practices. The responses from 43 centers across the country revealed considerable heterogeneity in tests and few trained and qualified neuropsychologists. In low- and middle-income countries (LMIC) with emerging neuropsychology services, there is a need to have uniform test protocols, specialized training, and guidelines for optimizing neuropsychology services across all the epilepsy surgery centers.
神经心理学在优化癫痫管理方面发挥着重要作用,但对于新兴服务的中低收入国家尚无实践指南。国家癫痫手术支持活动网络(NESSAN)是一个支持和优化印度癫痫手术项目的国家级工作组,该组织探索了印度各地癫痫手术前后神经心理学评估实践的现状,作为制定国家循证测试指南的第一步。该组织使用两个问卷进行了在线调查,一个问卷针对神经科医生,另一个问卷针对在癫痫手术中心工作的神经心理学家和言语语言病理学家。针对神经科医生的问卷涵盖了为成人和儿童提供的神经心理学服务的设置、描述和性质,以及他们对癫痫手术中神经心理学评估的重要性和适应证的看法。针对神经心理学家的问卷询问了他们的资格和培训、术前和术后评估程序以及特定领域的认知测试和用于评估情绪、生活质量和语言的量表。43 个中心做出了回应,四分之三的中心提供神经心理学服务,但只有 16%的中心有专门的全职神经心理学家。90%的神经科医生认为神经心理学评估是术前评估不可或缺的一部分。然而,只有少数人认为评估结果会影响他们对切除范围的决定以及是否进行手术的决定。调查发现,神经心理学家的资格和培训、评估程序、测试方案和规范数据方面存在相当大的异质性,需要进行协调,以确保全国范围内的统一实践。我们认为,这项调查的结果为实施措施提供了路线图,以最小化现有不足并协调印度以及其他新兴神经心理学服务国家的神经心理学服务。