Guha Rahul, Boehme Amelia, Demel Stacie L, Li Janet J, Cai Xuemei, James Michael L, Koch Sebastian, Langefeld Carl D, Moomaw Charles J, Osborne Jennifer, Sekar Padmini, Sheth Kevin N, Woodrich E, Worrall Bradford B, Woo Daniel, Chaturvedi Seemant
From the University of Virginia (R.G. and B.B.W.), Charlottesville; Columbia University (A.B.), New York, NY; University of Cincinnati (S.L.D., C.J.M., J.O., P.S., D.W.), OH; Georgetown University (J.J.L.), Washington, DC; Tufts Medical Center (X.C.), Boston, MA; Duke University (M.L.J.), Durham, NC; University of Miami (S.K., S.C.), FL; Wake Forest School of Medicine (C.D.L.), Winston-Salem, NC; Yale University School of Medicine (K.N.S.), New Haven, CT; and Banner University Medical Center Tucson (E.W.), AZ.
Neurology. 2017 Jul 25;89(4):349-354. doi: 10.1212/WNL.0000000000004143. Epub 2017 Jun 28.
To compare comorbidities and use of surgery and palliative care between men and women with intracerebral hemorrhage (ICH).
The Ethnic/Racial Variations of Intracerebral Hemorrhage (ERICH) study is a prospective, multicenter, case-control study of ICH risk factors and outcomes. We compared comorbidities, treatments, and use of do-not-resuscitate (DNR) orders in men vs women. Multivariate analysis was used to assess the likelihood of ICH surgery and palliative care after adjustment for variables that were < 0.1 in univariate analyses and backward elimination to retain those that were significant ( < 0.05).
Women were older on average (65.0 vs 59.9, < 0.0001), and higher proportions of women had previous stroke (24.1% vs 19.3%, = 0.002), had dementia (6.1% vs 3.4%, = 0.0007), lived alone (23.1% vs 18.0%, = 0.0005), and took anticoagulants (12.8% vs 10.1% = 0.02), compared with men. Men had higher rates of alcohol and cocaine use. After adjusting for age, hematoma volume, and ICH location, there was no difference in rates of surgical treatment by sex (odds ratio [OR] 0.93 for men vs women, 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.68-1.28, = 0.67), and there was no difference in DNR/comfort care decisions after adjustment for ICH score, prior stroke, and dementia (OR 0.96, CI 0.77-1.22, = 0.76).
After ICH, women do not receive less aggressive care than men after controlling for the substantial comorbidity differences. Future studies on sex bias should include the presence of comorbidities, prestroke disability, and other factors that may influence management.
比较脑出血(ICH)男性和女性患者的合并症以及手术和姑息治疗的使用情况。
脑出血的种族/民族差异(ERICH)研究是一项关于ICH危险因素和结局的前瞻性、多中心、病例对照研究。我们比较了男性和女性的合并症、治疗方法以及不进行心肺复苏(DNR)医嘱的使用情况。多变量分析用于评估在对单变量分析中P值<0.1的变量进行调整后,ICH手术和姑息治疗的可能性,并通过向后排除法保留那些具有显著性(P<0.05)的变量。
女性平均年龄更大(65.0岁对59.9岁,P<0.0001),与男性相比,有更高比例的女性曾患中风(24.1%对19.3%,P = 0.002)、患有痴呆症(6.1%对3.4%,P = 0.0007)、独居(23.1%对18.0%,P = 0.0005)以及服用抗凝剂(12.8%对10.1%,P = 0.02)。男性酒精和可卡因使用率更高。在调整年龄、血肿体积和ICH位置后,按性别划分的手术治疗率没有差异(男性对女性的优势比[OR]为0.93,95%置信区间[CI]为0.68 - 1.28,P = 0.67),在调整ICH评分、既往中风和痴呆症后,DNR/舒适护理决策也没有差异(OR为0.96,CI为0.77 - 1.22,P = 0.76)。
脑出血后,在控制了显著的合并症差异后,女性接受的积极治疗并不比男性少。未来关于性别偏见的研究应包括合并症的存在、中风前残疾以及其他可能影响治疗管理的因素。