Do Jun-Hyeong, Ku Boncho, Jang Jun-Su, Kim Honggie, Kim Jong Yeol
Constitutional Medicine and Diagnosis Research Group, Medical Research Division, Korea Institute of Oriental Medicine, Daejeon, Korea.
Department of Information and Statistics, Chungnam National University, Daejeon, Korea.
Integr Med Res. 2012 Dec;1(1):26-35. doi: 10.1016/j.imr.2012.09.003. Epub 2012 Oct 16.
Facial features are regarded as representative and reliable characteristics for diagnosing a person's Sasang Constitution (SC). However, the description of these features tends to depend on the interpretation and the opinion of the doctor that follows the SC approach. In this paper, we performed a facial feature analysis of SC types in an objective and quantitative manner. Here, site-to-site variability can be an obstacle to properly analyzing facial features when images are taken from various sites, which may have different experimental environments. A compensation technique to reduce the site-to-site variability was proposed before performing the feature analysis.
The frontal and profile images of 1464 patients recruited from various oriental medical clinics (19 sites) were used. Candidate feature variables were created, which were inspired by the facial characteristics of the SC types described in the Sasang constitutional medicine literature. To resolve the problems involved in processing data collected from various sites with heterogeneous experimental environments, a compensation technique was proposed. Statistical analysis techniques were employed to observe the differences among the SC types and to demonstrate how effectively the site-to-site variability was reduced.
The facial features that were significant for diagnosing the SC types were identified by a statistical analysis, and it was verified that the compensation technique reduced the site-to-site variability produced by the differences in photographic distance.
It is noted that the significant facial features represent common characteristics of each SC type in the sense that we collected extensive opinions from many Sasang constitutional medicine doctors with various points of view. Additionally, a compensation method for the photographic distance is needed to find the significant facial features. We expect these findings and the related compensation technique to contribute to establishing a scientific basis for the precise diagnosis of SC types in clinical practice.
面部特征被视为诊断一个人四象体质(SC)的典型且可靠的特征。然而,这些特征的描述往往取决于遵循四象体质方法的医生的解读和观点。在本文中,我们以客观和定量的方式对四象体质类型进行了面部特征分析。在此,当从不同地点拍摄图像时,由于可能存在不同的实验环境,位点间的变异性可能会成为正确分析面部特征的障碍。在进行特征分析之前,提出了一种减少位点间变异性的补偿技术。
使用了从各个韩医诊所(19个地点)招募的1464名患者的正面和侧面图像。根据四象体质医学文献中描述的四象体质类型的面部特征,创建了候选特征变量。为了解决处理从具有异质实验环境的不同地点收集的数据所涉及的问题,提出了一种补偿技术。采用统计分析技术来观察四象体质类型之间的差异,并证明位点间变异性是如何有效降低的。
通过统计分析确定了对诊断四象体质类型具有显著意义的面部特征,并验证了补偿技术减少了由拍摄距离差异产生的位点间变异性。
需要注意的是,这些显著的面部特征代表了每种四象体质类型的共同特征,因为我们从许多具有不同观点的四象体质医学医生那里收集了广泛的意见。此外,为了找到显著的面部特征,需要一种针对拍摄距离的补偿方法。我们期望这些发现和相关的补偿技术有助于为临床实践中四象体质类型的精确诊断建立科学依据。