Phillips Cameron J, McKinnon Ross A, Woodman Richard J, Gordon David L
Department of Pharmacy, Flinders Medical Centre, Bedford Park, SA, Australia.
School of Medicine, Flinders University, Adelaide, SA, Australia.
J Educ Eval Health Prof. 2017 Jun 7;14:13. doi: 10.3352/jeehp.2017.14.13. eCollection 2017.
We aimed to assess the preparedness of junior doctors to use vancomycin, and to determine whether attending an educational session and being provided pocket guidelines were associated with self-reported confidence and objective knowledge.
This was a 2-component cross-sectional study. A 60-minute educational session was implemented and pocket guidelines were provided. Preparedness was evaluated by a self-reported confidence survey in the early and late stages of each training year, and by continuing medical education (CME) knowledge scores.
Self-confidence was higher among those later in the training year (n=75) than in those earlier (n=120) in the year for all questions. In the late group, vancomycin education was associated with higher self-confidence regarding the frequency of therapeutic drug monitoring (P=0.02) and dose amendment (P=0.05); however, the confidence for initial monitoring was lower (P<0.05). Those with pocket guidelines were more confident treating patients with vancomycin (P<0.001), choosing initial (P=0.01) and maintenance doses (P<0.001), and knowing the monitoring frequency (P=0.03). The 85 respondents who completed the knowledge assessment scored a mean±standard deviation of 8.55±1.55 on 10 questions, and the interventions had no significant effect.
Attending an educational session and possessing pocket guidelines were associated with preparedness, as measured by higher self-reported confidence using vancomycin. High knowledge scores were attained following CME; however attending an educational session or possessing pocket guidelines did not significantly increase the knowledge scores. Our findings support providing educational sessions and pocket guidelines to increase self-confidence in prescribing vancomycin, yet also highlight the importance of evaluating content, format, and delivery when seeking to improve preparedness to use vancomycin through education.
我们旨在评估初级医生使用万古霉素的准备情况,并确定参加教育课程和获得袖珍指南是否与自我报告的信心及客观知识相关。
这是一项分为两个部分的横断面研究。实施了一场60分钟的教育课程并提供了袖珍指南。通过在每个培训年的早期和晚期进行的自我报告信心调查以及继续医学教育(CME)知识得分来评估准备情况。
对于所有问题,培训年后期的人员(n = 75)比同年早期的人员(n = 120)自信心更高。在后期组中,万古霉素教育与在治疗药物监测频率(P = 0.02)和剂量调整方面(P = 0.05)更高的自信心相关;然而,初始监测的信心较低(P < 0.05)。拥有袖珍指南的人员在使用万古霉素治疗患者方面(P < 0.001)、选择初始剂量(P = 0.01)和维持剂量(P < 0.001)以及知晓监测频率(P = 0.03)方面更有信心。完成知识评估的85名受访者在10个问题上的平均得分±标准差为8.55±1.55,且这些干预措施没有显著影响。
参加教育课程和拥有袖珍指南与准备情况相关,这通过使用万古霉素时更高的自我报告信心来衡量。继续医学教育后获得了较高的知识得分;然而,参加教育课程或拥有袖珍指南并未显著提高知识得分。我们的研究结果支持提供教育课程和袖珍指南以增强开具万古霉素处方时的自信心,但也强调了在试图通过教育提高使用万古霉素的准备情况时评估内容、形式和交付方式的重要性。