Clausen Caroline
Dan Med J. 2017 Jul;64(7).
An increasing number of patients develop symptomatic spinal metastasis and increasing evidence supports the benefit of surgical decompression and spinal stabilization combined with radiation therapy. However, surgery for metastatic spinal disease is known to be associated with a risk of substantial intraoperative blood loss and perioperative allogenic blood transfusion. Anemia is known to increase morbidity and mortality in patients undergoing surgery, but studies also indicate that transfusion with allogenic red blood cells (RBC) may lead to worse outcomes. To reduce intraoperative bleeding preoperative embolization has been used in selected cases suspected for hypervascular spinal metastases, but no randomized trial has examined the effect. The final decision on whether preoperative embolization should be performed is based on the preoperative digital subtraction angiography (DSA) tumor blush, and as such considered the "gold standard" for determining the vascularity of spinal metastases. Reliability studies evaluating vascularity ratings of DSA tumor blush have not been published before. This PhD thesis is based on three studies with the following aims: I. To assess whether perioperative allogenic blood transfusions in patients undergoing surgical treatment for spinal metastases independently influence patient survival (Study 1). II. To assess whether preoperative transcatheter arterial embolization of spinal metastases reduces blood loss, the need for transfusion with allogenic RBC and surgery time in the surgical treatment of patients with symptomatic metastatic spinal cord compression (Study 2). III. To describe the vascularity of metastasis causing spinal cord compression (Study 2). IV. To evaluate inter- and intra-observer agreement in the assessment of the vascularity of spinal metastases using DSA tumor blush (Study 3). In conclusion the findings of this thesis demonstrate that preoperative embolization in patients with symptomatic spinal metastasis independent of primary tumor diagnosis does not reduce intraoperative blood loss and the need for allogenic RBC transfusion significantly, but does reduce the surgery time. However, a small reduction of intraoperative blood loss was observed in the hypervascular metastases. This tendency could be underestimated because of the study design and furthermore the tendency may be enhanced in metastases of only the most pronounced hypervascularity. The findings furthermore support that perioperative blood transfusion of less than 5 units does not decrease survival in patients operated for spinal metastases and transfusion of 1-2 units seems to be weakly associated with increased 12-month survival. It was demonstrated that approximately 75 percent of spinal metastases are hypervascular in a consecutive series of patients with symptoms of metastatic medullary compression and spinal instability operated by decompression and instrumented spinal stabilization. In addition the findings show that there is satisfactory moderate inter- and intrarater agreement in classifying the vascularity of spinal metastases on a three-step ordinal scale for DSA tumor blush. Nevertheless, there is a call for an accurate preoperative way to evaluate the vascularity of spinal metastases in order to select patients most likely to benefit from preoperative embolization.
越来越多的患者出现有症状的脊柱转移,越来越多的证据支持手术减压和脊柱稳定联合放射治疗的益处。然而,已知转移性脊柱疾病的手术与术中大量失血和围手术期异体输血的风险相关。已知贫血会增加手术患者的发病率和死亡率,但研究也表明输注异体红细胞(RBC)可能导致更差的结果。为减少术中出血,术前栓塞已用于疑似高血供脊柱转移的特定病例,但尚无随机试验检验其效果。关于是否应进行术前栓塞的最终决定基于术前数字减影血管造影(DSA)肿瘤染色,因此被视为确定脊柱转移血管性的“金标准”。此前尚未发表评估DSA肿瘤染色血管评级可靠性的研究。本博士论文基于三项研究,目的如下:一、评估接受脊柱转移手术治疗的患者围手术期异体输血是否独立影响患者生存(研究1)。二、评估脊柱转移术前经导管动脉栓塞在有症状转移性脊髓压迫患者的手术治疗中是否能减少失血、异体RBC输血需求和手术时间(研究2)。三、描述导致脊髓压迫的转移瘤的血管性(研究2)。四、评估使用DSA肿瘤染色评估脊柱转移血管性时观察者间和观察者内的一致性(研究3)。总之,本论文的研究结果表明,有症状脊柱转移患者(无论原发肿瘤诊断如何)的术前栓塞并不能显著减少术中失血和异体RBC输血需求,但能缩短手术时间。然而,在高血供转移瘤中观察到术中失血有少量减少。由于研究设计,这种趋势可能被低估,此外,这种趋势在仅最明显高血供的转移瘤中可能会增强。研究结果还支持,接受脊柱转移手术的患者围手术期输血少于5单位不会降低生存率,输注1 - 2单位似乎与12个月生存率增加有弱关联。在一系列因转移性髓质压迫和脊柱不稳定症状而接受减压和器械辅助脊柱稳定手术的患者中,约75%的脊柱转移瘤为高血供。此外,研究结果表明,在使用DSA肿瘤染色对脊柱转移瘤血管性进行三步序贯评分时,观察者间和观察者内有令人满意的中度一致性。然而,仍需要一种准确的术前方法来评估脊柱转移瘤的血管性,以便选择最可能从术前栓塞中获益的患者。