Struck Aaron F, Osman Gamaleldin, Rampal Nishi, Biswal Siddhartha, Legros Benjamin, Hirsch Lawrence J, Westover M Brandon, Gaspard Nicolas
Department of Neurology, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI.
Department of Neurology, Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, CT.
Ann Neurol. 2017 Aug;82(2):177-185. doi: 10.1002/ana.24985. Epub 2017 Jul 19.
Find the optimal continuous electroencephalographic (CEEG) monitoring duration for seizure detection in critically ill patients.
We analyzed prospective data from 665 consecutive CEEGs, including clinical factors and time-to-event emergence of electroencephalographic (EEG) findings over 72 hours. Clinical factors were selected using logistic regression. EEG risk factors were selected a priori. Clinical factors were used for baseline (pre-EEG) risk. EEG findings were used for the creation of a multistate survival model with 3 states (entry, EEG risk, and seizure). EEG risk state is defined by emergence of epileptiform patterns.
The clinical variables of greatest predictive value were coma (31% had seizures; odds ratio [OR] = 1.8, p < 0.01) and history of seizures, either remotely or related to acute illness (34% had seizures; OR = 3.0, p < 0.001). If there were no epileptiform findings on EEG, the risk of seizures within 72 hours was between 9% (no clinical risk factors) and 36% (coma and history of seizures). If epileptiform findings developed, the seizure incidence was between 18% (no clinical risk factors) and 64% (coma and history of seizures). In the absence of epileptiform EEG abnormalities, the duration of monitoring needed for seizure risk of <5% was between 0.4 hours (for patients who are not comatose and had no prior seizure) and 16.4 hours (comatose and prior seizure).
The initial risk of seizures on CEEG is dependent on history of prior seizures and presence of coma. The risk of developing seizures on CEEG decays to <5% by 24 hours if no epileptiform EEG abnormalities emerge, independent of initial clinical risk factors. Ann Neurol 2017;82:177-185.
确定重症患者癫痫发作检测的最佳连续脑电图(CEEG)监测时长。
我们分析了665例连续CEEG的前瞻性数据,包括临床因素以及72小时内脑电图(EEG)结果的事件发生时间。使用逻辑回归选择临床因素。EEG危险因素预先选定。临床因素用于基线(EEG前)风险评估。EEG结果用于创建一个具有3种状态(起始、EEG风险和癫痫发作)的多状态生存模型。EEG风险状态由癫痫样放电模式的出现来定义。
预测价值最大的临床变量是昏迷(31%发生癫痫发作;比值比[OR]=1.8,p<0.01)以及癫痫发作史,无论是既往还是与急性疾病相关(34%发生癫痫发作;OR=3.0,p<0.001)。如果EEG上没有癫痫样放电发现,72小时内癫痫发作的风险在9%(无临床危险因素)至36%(昏迷和癫痫发作史)之间。如果出现癫痫样放电发现,癫痫发作发生率在18%(无临床危险因素)至64%(昏迷和癫痫发作史)之间。在没有EEG癫痫样异常的情况下,癫痫发作风险<5%所需的监测时长在0.4小时(非昏迷且无既往癫痫发作的患者)至16.4小时(昏迷且有既往癫痫发作的患者)之间。
CEEG上癫痫发作的初始风险取决于既往癫痫发作史和昏迷情况。如果没有出现EEG癫痫样异常,CEEG上癫痫发作的风险在24小时时降至<5%,与初始临床危险因素无关。《神经病学纪事》2017年;82卷:177 - 185页