Chiarini Andrea, Vagnoni Emidia
Department of Economics and Management, University of Ferrara , Ferrara, Italy.
Leadersh Health Serv (Bradf Engl). 2017 Jul 3;30(3):210-216. doi: 10.1108/LHS-02-2017-0004.
Purpose The purpose of this paper is to enlarge the debate on total quality management (TQM) implementation in the healthcare sector and to evaluate how and whether leadership can affect TQM implementation. Design/methodology/approach This paper is based on findings from a literature review of TQM and leadership. The authors analysed these findings to categorise causes of a lack of leadership in TQM programme implementations. Findings The authors propose three categories of causes of a lack of leadership in TQM programme implementation. The first cause is well-known: a lack of senior managers' involvement and commitment. The second category is the "combined leadership" that occurs in large healthcare organisations; and the third category is the influence of an external "political leadership" on public healthcare. Research limitations/implications This paper presents researchers with three categories of causes of failure of leadership in TQM implementation that can be investigated. It also encourages reflections from practitioners concerning TQM leadership in the healthcare sector. Practical implications The authors request that practitioners reflect on ways to create or sustain a "monolithic" leadership, especially in large organisations, to ensure a common vision, values and attitude for unitary TQM governance. Originality/value In an original way, this paper analyses and proposes three categories of causes linked to a lack of TQM leadership in the healthcare sector.
目的 本文旨在扩大关于医疗保健部门全面质量管理(TQM)实施的辩论,并评估领导力如何以及是否会影响TQM的实施。
设计/方法/途径 本文基于对TQM和领导力的文献综述结果。作者分析这些结果,对TQM计划实施中领导力缺失的原因进行分类。
发现 作者提出了TQM计划实施中领导力缺失的三类原因。第一个原因众所周知:高层管理人员缺乏参与和承诺。第二类是大型医疗保健组织中出现的“联合领导力”;第三类是外部“政治领导力”对公共医疗保健的影响。
研究局限/影响 本文为研究人员提供了TQM实施中领导力失败的三类可调查原因。它还鼓励从业者对医疗保健部门的TQM领导力进行反思。
实际意义 作者要求从业者思考如何创建或维持“整体式”领导力,尤其是在大型组织中,以确保统一的TQM治理有共同的愿景、价值观和态度。
原创性/价值 本文以一种原创的方式分析并提出了与医疗保健部门TQM领导力缺失相关的三类原因。