Gibbs Jenna C, Gagnon Dany H, Bergquist Austin J, Arel Jasmine, Cervinka Tomas, El-Kotob Rasha, Maltais Désirée B, Wolfe Dalton L, Craven B Catharine
a Department of Kinesiology , University of Waterloo , Waterloo , ON , Canada.
c University Health Network-Toronto Rehabilitation Institute, Lyndhurst Centre , Toronto , ON , Canada.
J Spinal Cord Med. 2017 Nov;40(6):733-747. doi: 10.1080/10790268.2017.1350341. Epub 2017 Jul 13.
Endocrine-metabolic disease (EMD) risk following spinal cord injury (SCI) is associated with significant multi-morbidity (i.e. fracture, diabetes, heart disease), mortality, and economic burden. It is unclear to what extent rehabilitation interventions can modify EMD risk and improve health status in community-dwelling adults with chronic SCI.
To characterize rehabilitation interventions and summarize evidence on their efficacy/effectiveness to modify precursors to EMD risk in community-dwelling adults with chronic SCI.
Systematic searches of MEDLINE PubMed, EMBASE Ovid, CINAHL, CDSR, and PsychInfo were completed. All randomized, quasi-experimental, and prospective controlled trials comparing rehabilitation/therapeutic interventions with control/placebo interventions in adults with chronic SCI were eligible. Two authors independently selected studies and abstracted data. Mean differences of change from baseline were reported for EMD risk outcomes. The GRADE approach was used to rate the quality of evidence.
Of 489 articles identified, 16 articles (11 studies; n=396) were eligible for inclusion. No studies assessed the effects of rehabilitation interventions on incident fragility fractures, heart disease, and/or diabetes. Individual studies reported that exercise and/or nutrition interventions could improve anthropometric indices, body composition/adiposity, and biomarkers. However, there were also reports of non-statistically significant between-group differences.
There was very low-quality evidence that rehabilitation interventions can improve precursors to EMD risk in community-dwelling adults with chronic SCI. The small number of studies, imprecise estimates, and inconsistency across studies limited our ability to make conclusions. A high-quality longitudinal intervention trial is needed to inform community-based rehabilitation strategies for EMD risk after chronic SCI.
脊髓损伤(SCI)后的内分泌代谢疾病(EMD)风险与严重的多种疾病(如骨折、糖尿病、心脏病)、死亡率及经济负担相关。目前尚不清楚康复干预在多大程度上能够改变社区居住的慢性SCI成年患者的EMD风险并改善其健康状况。
描述康复干预措施,并总结其在改变社区居住的慢性SCI成年患者EMD风险先兆方面的疗效/有效性证据。
完成了对MEDLINE PubMed、EMBASE Ovid、CINAHL、CDSR和PsychInfo的系统检索。所有比较康复/治疗干预与慢性SCI成年患者对照/安慰剂干预的随机、准实验和前瞻性对照试验均符合要求。两位作者独立选择研究并提取数据。报告了EMD风险结局相对于基线变化的平均差异。采用GRADE方法对证据质量进行评级。
在检索到的489篇文章中,有16篇文章(11项研究;n = 396)符合纳入标准。没有研究评估康复干预对脆性骨折、心脏病和/或糖尿病发病的影响。个别研究报告称,运动和/或营养干预可改善人体测量指标、身体成分/肥胖状况及生物标志物。然而,也有报告称组间差异无统计学意义。
证据质量极低,表明康复干预可改善社区居住的慢性SCI成年患者的EMD风险先兆。研究数量少、估计不精确以及研究结果不一致限制了我们得出结论的能力。需要开展一项高质量的纵向干预试验,为慢性SCI后EMD风险的社区康复策略提供依据。