Mor Zohar, Raveh Yuval, Lurie Ido, Leventhal Alex, Gamzu Roni, Davidovitch Nadav, Benari Orel, Grotto Itamar
Tel Aviv Department of Health Tel Aviv, 12 Ha'arba'a St, 6473912, Tel Aviv, Israel.
Faculty of Medicine, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv, Israel.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2017 Jul 14;17(1):484. doi: 10.1186/s12913-017-2421-y.
Approximately 150,000 undocumented migrants (UM) who are medically uninsured reside in Israel, including ~50,000 originating from the horn of Africa (MHA). Free medical-care is provided by two walk-in clinics in Tel-Aviv. This study aims to compare the medical complaints of UM from different origins, define their community health needs and assess gaps between medical needs and available services.
This cross-sectional study included a random sample of 610 UM aged 18-64 years, who were treated in these community clinics between 2008 and 2011. The study compared UM who had complex medical conditions which necessitated referral to more equipped medical settings with UM having mild/simple medical conditions, who were treated at the clinics.
MHA were younger, unemployed and more commonly males compared with UM originating from other countries. MHA also had longer referral-delays and visited the clinics less frequently. UM with complex medical conditions were more commonly females, had chronic diseases and demonstrated longer referral-delays than those who had mild/simple medical conditions. The latter more commonly presented with complained of respiratory, muscular and skeletal discomfort. In multivariate analysis, the variables which predicted complex medical conditions included female gender, chronic illnes and self-referral to the clinics.
The ambulatory clinics were capable of responding to mild/simple medical conditions. Yet, the health needs of women and migrants suffering from complex medical conditions and chronic diseases necessitated referrals to secondary/tertiary medical settings, while jeopardizing the continuity of care. The health gaps can be addressed by a more holistic social approach, which includes integration of UM in universal health insurance.
约15万没有医保的无证移民居住在以色列,其中约5万来自非洲之角(非洲之角移民)。特拉维夫的两家无需预约的诊所提供免费医疗服务。本研究旨在比较不同来源的无证移民的医疗诉求,确定他们的社区健康需求,并评估医疗需求与现有服务之间的差距。
这项横断面研究纳入了2008年至2011年间在这些社区诊所接受治疗的610名18至64岁无证移民的随机样本。该研究将有复杂医疗状况、需要转诊至设备更齐全医疗机构的无证移民与在诊所接受治疗的患有轻度/简单医疗状况的无证移民进行了比较。
与来自其他国家的无证移民相比,非洲之角移民更年轻、失业且男性更为常见。非洲之角移民的转诊延迟也更长,就诊频率更低。患有复杂医疗状况的无证移民女性更为常见,患有慢性病,且转诊延迟比患有轻度/简单医疗状况的人更长。后者更常出现呼吸道、肌肉和骨骼不适的主诉。在多变量分析中,预测复杂医疗状况的变量包括女性性别、慢性病和自行前往诊所就诊。
门诊诊所能够应对轻度/简单的医疗状况。然而,患有复杂医疗状况和慢性病的妇女及移民的健康需求需要转诊至二级/三级医疗机构,这会危及医疗的连续性。可以通过更全面的社会方法来解决健康差距问题,这包括将无证移民纳入全民健康保险。