McCaffrey Eden S N, Chang Samuel, Farrelly Geraldine, Rahman Abdul, Cawthorpe David
Department of Psychiatry, Alberta Health Services, University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta, Canada.
Department of Psychiatry, Alberta Health Services, University of Calgary Cumming School of Medicine, Calgary, Alberta, Canada.
Evid Based Med. 2017 Aug;22(4):123-131. doi: 10.1136/ebmed-2017-110714. Epub 2017 Jul 22.
The effectiveness of a continuing education programme in paediatric psychopharmacology designed for primary healthcare providers was objectively measured based on the assumption that training would lead to measurable changes in referral patterns and established clinical measures of referred patients. Using established, valid and reliable measures of clinical urgency embedded in to a regional healthcare system since 2002, the referrals to child and adolescent psychiatric services of physicians who participated in the training (n=99) were compared pretraining and post-training, and to non-participating/untrained referring physicians (n=7753) making referrals over the same time period. Referrals were analysed for evidence of change based on frequencies and measures of clinical urgency. Participants of the training programme also completed standardised baseline and outcome self-evaluations. Congruent with participants self-reported evaluative reports of improved knowledge and practice, analysis of referral frequency and the clinical urgency of referrals to paediatric psychiatric services over the study period indicated that trained physicians made more appropriate referrals (clinically more severe) and reduced referrals to emergency services. Quantitative clinical differences as completed by intake clinicians blind to referrals from the study group designations were observed within the trained physician group pretraining and post-training, and between the trained physician group and the unexposed physician group. The results illustrate a novel model for objectively measuring change among physicians based on training in paediatric mental health management.
针对初级医疗服务提供者设计的儿科精神药理学继续教育项目的有效性,是基于培训将导致转诊模式以及转诊患者既定临床指标发生可测量变化这一假设进行客观衡量的。自2002年起,利用嵌入区域医疗系统的既定、有效且可靠的临床紧急程度衡量指标,对参与培训的医生(n = 99)在培训前和培训后的儿童及青少年精神科服务转诊情况,与同期进行转诊的未参与培训/未接受训练的转诊医生(n = 7753)进行了比较。根据频率和临床紧急程度指标,对转诊情况进行了变化证据分析。培训项目参与者还完成了标准化的基线和结果自我评估。与参与者自我报告的知识和实践改善评估报告一致,对研究期间转诊至儿科精神科服务的频率和临床紧急程度分析表明,经过培训的医生进行了更恰当的转诊(临床症状更严重),并减少了急诊服务转诊。在培训医生组培训前和培训后以及培训医生组与未接受培训医生组之间,观察到了由对研究组指定转诊不知情的接诊临床医生完成的定量临床差异。研究结果展示了一种基于儿科心理健康管理培训客观衡量医生变化的新模型。