Bradbury Hospice, New Territories East Cluster, Hospital Authority, Hong Kong SAR, China.
The Nethersole School of Nursing, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong SAR, China.
J Clin Nurs. 2017 Dec;26(23-24):4201-4211. doi: 10.1111/jocn.13977. Epub 2017 Oct 1.
To conduct an integrative review of the current literature on using life review as an intervention to address the spiritual need of patients with terminal illnesses.
Palliative care highlights the holistic approach of care including the spiritual aspect. Life review has been used in palliative nursing intending to enhance patients' emotional and spiritual well-being, and quality of life. However, there is a lack of publications that provide a structured overview on life review programmes and their effectiveness.
Integrative review.
The Whittemore and Knafl integrative review method was used. Five major online databases were included in our literature search. The keywords used were "life review" and "palliative care, terminal care, terminally ill, death & dying, hospice, spiritual wellbeing, spirituality". Seven primary papers were identified, critically appraised and synthesised in the final review.
There are limited clinical studies on life review programmes for patients with terminal illness. The research design of these studies is too widely varied for meta-analysis. Here, we identified two major programmes of life review as an intervention to address the spiritual well-being of patients with terminal illness. However, repeated studies on the effectiveness of these two programmes are lacking. The shorter programme of life review is more likely to be applicable and effective for terminal patients.
Further research in this area is required to provide strong evidence on the effectiveness and applicability of life review in patients receiving palliative care.
This review adds weight to the need of a better understanding on the use of life review in addressing the spiritual needs of patients with terminal illness. Such understanding would provide evidence for the use of life review as an alternative approach in palliative care delivery.
对目前使用生命回顾作为干预措施来满足终末期疾病患者精神需求的文献进行综合回顾。
姑息治疗强调包括精神方面在内的整体护理方法。生命回顾已在姑息护理中使用,旨在增强患者的情感和精神福祉以及生活质量。然而,缺乏关于生命回顾计划及其效果的结构化概述的出版物。
综合回顾。
使用 Whittemore 和 Knafl 综合审查方法。我们的文献搜索包括五个主要的在线数据库。使用的关键词是“生命回顾”和“姑息治疗、终末期护理、临终关怀、死亡与垂死、临终关怀、精神健康、精神性”。确定了七篇主要论文,对其进行了批判性评价并在最终综述中进行了综合。
终末期疾病患者生命回顾计划的临床研究有限。这些研究的研究设计差异太大,无法进行荟萃分析。在这里,我们确定了两项作为干预措施的生命回顾计划,以满足终末期患者的精神福祉。然而,这些计划的有效性的重复研究却缺乏。生命回顾的短期计划更有可能适用于终末期患者。
需要在这一领域进行进一步研究,以提供关于生命回顾在姑息治疗中对患者的有效性和适用性的有力证据。
本综述强调了更好地理解生命回顾在满足终末期疾病患者精神需求中的作用的必要性。这种理解将为生命回顾作为姑息治疗提供替代方法的使用提供证据。