Devinsky Orrin, Friedman Daniel, Cheng Jocelyn Y, Moffatt Ellen, Kim Anthony, Tseng Zian H
From the Department of Neurology (O.D., D.F., J.Y.C.), Epilepsy Center, NYU School of Medicine; and Department of Pathology (E.M.), Department of Neurology (A.K.), and Electrophysiology and Arrhythmia Service (Z.H.T.), Department of Medicine, UCSF School of Medicine.
Neurology. 2017 Aug 29;89(9):886-892. doi: 10.1212/WNL.0000000000004292. Epub 2017 Aug 2.
To determine the definite and potential frequency of seizures and epilepsy as a cause of death (COD) and how often this goes unrecognized.
Prospective determination of seizures or epilepsy and final COD for individuals aged 18-90 years with out-of-hospital sudden cardiac deaths (SCDs) from the population-based San Francisco POST SCD Study. We compared prospective seizure or epilepsy diagnosis and final COD as adjudicated by a multidisciplinary committee (pathologists, electrophysiologists, and a vascular neurologist) vs retrospective adjudication by 2 epileptologists with expertise in seizure-related mortality.
Of 541 SCDs identified during the 37-month study period (mean age 62.8 years, 69% men), 525 (97%) were autopsied; 39/525 (7.4%) had seizures or epilepsy (mean age: 58 years, range: 27-92; 67% men), comprising 17% of 231 nonarrhythmic sudden deaths. The multidisciplinary team identified 15 cases of epilepsy, 6 sudden unexpected deaths in epilepsy (SUDEPs), and no deaths related to acute symptomatic seizures. The epileptologists identified 25 cases of epilepsy and 8 definite SUDEPs, 10 possible SUDEPs, and 5 potential cases of acute symptomatic seizures as a COD.
Among the 25 patients identified with epilepsy by the epileptologists, they found definite or possible SUDEP in 72% (18/25) vs 24% (6/25) by the multidisciplinary group (6/15 cases they identified with epilepsy). The epileptologists identified acute symptomatic seizures as a potential COD in 5/14 patients with alcohol-related seizures. Epilepsy is underdiagnosed among decedents. Among patients with seizures and epilepsy who die suddenly, seizures and SUDEP often go unrecognized as a potential or definite COD.
确定癫痫发作和癫痫作为死亡原因(COD)的确切和潜在发生率,以及其未被识别的频率。
基于人群的旧金山POST心脏性猝死研究对18至90岁院外心脏性猝死(SCD)个体的癫痫发作或癫痫及最终COD进行前瞻性判定。我们比较了多学科委员会(病理学家、电生理学家和血管神经学家)判定的前瞻性癫痫发作或癫痫诊断及最终COD与两名具有癫痫相关死亡率专业知识的癫痫专家的回顾性判定结果。
在37个月的研究期间确定的541例SCD中(平均年龄62.8岁,69%为男性),525例(97%)进行了尸检;39/525例(7.4%)有癫痫发作或癫痫(平均年龄:58岁,范围:27 - 92岁;67%为男性),占231例非心律失常性猝死的17%。多学科团队确定了15例癫痫、6例癫痫性意外猝死(SUDEP),且无与急性症状性癫痫发作相关的死亡。癫痫专家确定了25例癫痫、8例明确的SUDEP、10例可能的SUDEP以及5例可能的急性症状性癫痫发作作为COD。
在癫痫专家确定的25例癫痫患者中,他们发现明确或可能的SUDEP占72%(18/25),而多学科小组为24%(6/25)(他们确定的15例癫痫病例中有6例)。癫痫专家在5/14例与酒精相关癫痫发作的患者中确定急性症状性癫痫发作是潜在的COD。癫痫在死者中诊断不足。在突然死亡的癫痫发作和癫痫患者中癫痫发作和SUDEP常未被识别为潜在或明确的COD。