Department of Neurology, Karolinska University Hospital, Stockholm, Sweden.
Department of Clinical Neuroscience, Karolinska Institute, Stockholm, Sweden.
Epilepsia. 2018 May;59(5):1074-1082. doi: 10.1111/epi.14079. Epub 2018 Apr 17.
Given the increasing attention being paid to potential strategies for sudden unexpected death in epilepsy (SUDEP) prevention, we analyzed the circumstances of SUDEP and its incidence in relation to time of year, week, and day.
Prospective case-series based on persons with an International Classification of Diseases (ICD-10) code for epilepsy in the Swedish Patient Registry 1998-2005, who were alive on June 30, 2006 (n = 60 952). Linkage to the National Cause-of-Death Registry identified all deaths from July 2006 through December 2011, with epilepsy mentioned on death certificate, together with all deaths during 2008 (n = 3166). Death certificates, medical charts, autopsy, and police reports were reviewed to identify SUDEP cases and related circumstances. Autopsied non-SUDEP deaths (n = 60) from the study population served as a reference.
There were 329 SUDEPs (63% men) of which 167 were definite, 89 probable, and 73 possible. SUDEP cases were younger at death (50.8 years) than non-SUDEP deaths (73.3 years) (P < .001) and more likely to be male (63% vs 55%, P = .0079). Most SUDEP cases died at night (58%), at home (91%), and 65% were found dead in bed. When documented, 70% were found in prone position. In 17%, death was witnessed and in 88% of these, a seizure was observed. Of the 329 SUDEP cases, 71% were living alone and 14% shared a bedroom. Compared to an autopsied non-SUDEP reference group, definite SUDEPs were more likely to die at home, during the night, unwitnessed, in the prone position, to live alone, and more often with a preceding seizure.
SUDEP cases live alone, die unwitnessed at home at night, with indication of a preceding seizure, supporting the critical role of lack of supervision. These facts need to be considered in the development of preventive strategies.
鉴于人们越来越关注癫痫猝死(SUDEP)预防的潜在策略,我们分析了 SUDEP 的发生情况及其与一年中时间、周和日的关系。
基于瑞典患者登记处 1998-2005 年 ICD-10 编码为癫痫的患者进行前瞻性病例系列研究,这些患者在 2006 年 6 月 30 日仍存活(n=60952)。与国家死因登记处的链接确定了 2006 年 7 月至 2011 年 12 月期间所有的死亡情况,死亡证明上提到了癫痫,以及 2008 年期间的所有死亡情况(n=3166)。对死亡证明、病历、尸检和警方报告进行了审查,以确定 SUDEP 病例和相关情况。该研究人群中未经尸检的非 SUDEP 死亡(n=60)作为参考。
有 329 例 SUDEP(63%为男性),其中 167 例为明确诊断,89 例为可能诊断,73 例为可疑诊断。SUDEP 病例的死亡年龄(50.8 岁)比非 SUDEP 死亡(73.3 岁)年轻(P<0.001),且更可能为男性(63%比 55%,P=0.0079)。大多数 SUDEP 病例在夜间(58%)、在家中(91%)死亡,65%的人在床上被发现死亡。当有记录时,70%的人处于俯卧位。17%的死亡有人目击,在这些人中,88%的人观察到癫痫发作。在 329 例 SUDEP 病例中,71%的人独居,14%的人共用卧室。与未经尸检的非 SUDEP 参考组相比,明确诊断的 SUDEP 更有可能在家中、夜间、无人目击、俯卧位死亡,独居的可能性更大,且更常伴有前驱性癫痫发作。
SUDEP 病例独居,夜间在家中无人目击死亡,伴有前驱性癫痫发作的迹象,这表明缺乏监管是至关重要的。这些事实在制定预防策略时需要考虑。