Zea Vera Alonso, Aungaroon Gewalin, Horn Paul S, Byars Anna W, Greiner Hansel M, Tenney Jeffrey R, Arthur Todd M, Crone Nathan E, Holland Katherine D, Mangano Francesco T, Arya Ravindra
Comprehensive Epilepsy Center, Division of Neurology, Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center, Cincinnati, Ohio, USA.
Department of Neurology, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland, USA.
Clin Neurophysiol. 2017 Oct;128(10):2087-2093. doi: 10.1016/j.clinph.2017.07.006. Epub 2017 Jul 18.
To examine current thresholds and their determinants for language and motor mapping with extra-operative electrical cortical stimulation (ECS).
ECS electrocorticograph recordings were reviewed to determine functional thresholds. Predictors of functional thresholds were found with multivariable analyses.
In 122 patients (age 11.9±5.4years), average minimum, frontal, and temporal language thresholds were 7.4 (± 3.0), 7.8 (± 3.0), and 7.4 (± 3.1) mA respectively. Average minimum, face, upper and lower extremity motor thresholds were 5.4 (± 2.8), 6.1 (± 2.8), 4.9 (± 2.3), and 5.3 (± 3.3) mA respectively. Functional and after-discharge (AD)/seizure thresholds were significantly related. Minimum, frontal, and temporal language thresholds were higher than AD thresholds at all ages. Minimum motor threshold was higher than minimum AD threshold up to 8.0years of age, face motor threshold was higher than frontal AD threshold up to 11.8years age, and lower subsequently. UE motor thresholds remained below frontal AD thresholds throughout the age range.
Functional thresholds are frequently above AD thresholds in younger children.
These findings raise concerns about safety and neurophysiologic validity of ECS mapping. Functional and AD/seizure thresholds relationships suggest individual differences in cortical excitability which cannot be explained by clinical variables.
通过术中皮层电刺激(ECS)检查当前语言和运动功能区定位的阈值及其决定因素。
回顾ECS脑电图记录以确定功能阈值。通过多变量分析找出功能阈值的预测因素。
122例患者(年龄11.9±5.4岁),平均最小、额叶和颞叶语言阈值分别为7.4(±3.0)、7.8(±3.0)和7.4(±3.1)毫安。平均最小、面部、上肢和下肢运动阈值分别为5.4(±2.8)、6.1(±2.8)、4.9(±2.3)和5.3(±3.3)毫安。功能阈值与放电后(AD)/癫痫阈值显著相关。所有年龄段的最小、额叶和颞叶语言阈值均高于AD阈值。直至8.0岁,最小运动阈值高于最小AD阈值;直至11.8岁,面部运动阈值高于额叶AD阈值,之后则较低。在整个年龄范围内,上肢运动阈值均低于额叶AD阈值。
年幼儿童的功能阈值通常高于AD阈值。
这些发现引发了对ECS定位安全性和神经生理有效性的担忧。功能阈值与AD/癫痫阈值的关系表明皮层兴奋性存在个体差异,而这无法用临床变量来解释。