Singh A, Alpert M A, Sanfelippo J F, Mukerji V, Villarreal D, Holmes R A, Sunderrajan E V, Morgan R J
Arch Intern Med. 1986 Nov;146(11):2135-9.
To assess the effects of beta-blockade on right ventricular performance in patients with and without right ventricular dysfunction due to coronary artery disease, we performed radionuclide ventriculography on eight patients with normal right ventricular ejection fraction (RVEF greater than or equal to 35%) and 14 patients with mild to moderate right ventricular dysfunction (RVEF less than 35%) at rest. All patients had chronic stable angina pectoris, and nine patients had prior myocardial infarction. Radionuclide ventriculography was performed on placebo and during clinical beta-blockade (heart rate, 50 to 60 beats per minute and less than or equal to 20% increase in heart rate over baseline during stage I treadmill exercise, Bruce protocol) with the oral, cardioselective beta-blocking agent, betaxolol. The resting RVEF (mean +/- 1 SD) was 33% +/- 7% on placebo and 34% +/- 7% during clinical beta-blockade. Mean exercise RVEF was 40% +/- 8% on placebo and 39% +/- 8% during clinical beta-blockade. These differences were not statistically significant. Resting left ventricular ejection fraction ranged from 22% to 60% (mean, 42% +/- 8%). On placebo, one of eight patients with a resting RVEF greater than or equal to 35% had a normal exercise RVEF response (greater than or equal to 5% increment) whereas nine of 14 patients with resting RVEF less than 35% had normal exercise response. The discordant relationship between baseline RVEF and exercise response on placebo became less marked during clinical beta-blockade. We conclude that beta-blockade does not produce significant deterioration of right ventricular systolic function or right ventricular reserve either in patients with normal or in those with mild to moderately impaired resting right ventricular systolic function.
为评估β受体阻滞剂对因冠状动脉疾病导致或未导致右心室功能障碍患者右心室功能的影响,我们对8例静息状态下右心室射血分数(RVEF大于或等于35%)正常的患者和14例轻至中度右心室功能障碍(RVEF小于35%)的患者进行了放射性核素心室造影。所有患者均患有慢性稳定性心绞痛,其中9例有心肌梗死病史。使用口服心脏选择性β受体阻滞剂倍他洛尔,在服用安慰剂期间及临床β受体阻滞剂治疗期间(心率为每分钟50至60次,且在I级平板运动试验[Bruce方案]期间心率较基线增加小于或等于20%)进行放射性核素心室造影。服用安慰剂时静息RVEF(均值±1标准差)为33%±7%,临床β受体阻滞剂治疗期间为34%±7%。平均运动RVEF在服用安慰剂时为40%±8%,临床β受体阻滞剂治疗期间为39%±8%。这些差异无统计学意义。静息左心室射血分数范围为22%至60%(均值,42%±8%)。服用安慰剂时,8例静息RVEF大于或等于35%的患者中有1例运动RVEF反应正常(增加大于或等于5%),而14例静息RVEF小于35%的患者中有9例运动反应正常。在临床β受体阻滞剂治疗期间,基线RVEF与服用安慰剂时运动反应之间的不一致关系变得不那么明显。我们得出结论,无论是静息右心室收缩功能正常的患者还是静息右心室收缩功能轻度至中度受损的患者,β受体阻滞剂均不会导致右心室收缩功能或右心室储备显著恶化。